Trusted Agent profile

Verified

Mather Marshall reviews

4.5

★★★★★ Excellent

581 reviews across 3 offices and 4 platforms

www.mathermarshall.com

Mather Marshall has 581 reviews across three offices (Stevenage, Hatfield and Knebworth) and four platforms, rated 4.5 out of 5 overall. Mather Marshall has the most, 307. Checked 9 October 2026.

Google logo

4.3 / 5

418

Reviews on Google

All 3 offices

Facebook logo

5.0 / 5

31

Reviews on Facebook

All 3 offices

View Agents logo

4.9 / 5

129

Reviews on View Agents

All 3 offices

Trustpilot logo

3

Reviews on Trustpilot

All 3 offices

Reviews may appear on more than one platform. A review shared by several offices is counted once.

Reviews by type

What sellers, buyers, landlords and tenants say, where the review tells us who wrote it.

Our offices

Mather Marshall's three offices, most reviewed first. Each has its own page.

Latest reviews from every Mather Marshall office

Newest first, from every platform, with the office each review is about. First names only.

5/5

View Agents
Buyer

Friendly, efficient and professional!

James at Mather Marshall helped us buy our first home. He was always happy to help and efficient with dealing with any queries we had to help the sale go through smoothly and quickly. Thank you to James and all at Mather Marshall for all your help.

Abbie · 6 October 2015 · Mather Marshall

1/5

Google

Rating only, no written review.

Bee · 26 June 2015 · Mather Marshall

Agent replied

Dear Mr Bhamber The lettings business was originally owned by a Mrs D Norris who has now left and I Paul Mather am once again running this side of the business I apologise for any bad experience you received and hope now that the staff have changed we can assist you in the future all the best Paul Mather

1/5

Google

If you scraped the bottom of the barrel you would come out with a more competent and capable set of workers than this estate agent. Personal experience as well as countless friends have led me to the conclusion that this is an estate agent to avoid at all costs. Unless of course you are prepared to lose at least 50% of your deposit; the majority of which is over damages prior to your tenancy. Surely an inventory would prove otherwise you may ask? Wrong. Inventories are down to the landlord, and from my experience no inventory was done, despite contrary claims. To save myself and the reader some time, bullet-pointed are just some of the key issues i found with Mather Marshall. - Landlord (Joint owner of the estate agent) squares up to me in office and threatens me when confronted upon the issue of why the return of my deposit was 2 months late. - During tenancy landlord/agent was called numerous times concerning various issues with the house such as faulty boiler. Nothing was done. - Mold was growing in one of the rooms. The proposed solution? Keep window open all day (during winter!). - Charge for wear and tear. - Charge £66 for extremely cheap door handle. - Charge over £1000 all together for redecoration due to a couple of blu-tack stains which were there prior to tenancy. - Charge for "hole in wall". Once it was proved with pictures that the hole existed prior to the tenancy, charge was removed and another charge for scraped banister was added to compensate. - General rudeness and inefficiency of staff prior to, during and after tenancy. From the first day it was obvious that I would eventually have to settle matters through court which is exactly what happened. They charge students for the same things year in year out, putting deposits into their pocket and leaving the house in the same condition. Condition of the houses are shocking, landlords are nowhere to be seen during the tenancy and everywhere to be seen when the time comes to pocket deposits, and the staff couldn't organize a piss-up in a brewery. I feel like this is one of those estate agents that one picks out of naivety and thus only has the unfortunate experience of renting for a year. Never again. Underestimate their surreal incompetence at your peril.

Norire · 1 May 2015 · Mather Marshall

Agent replied

Dear Norire The lettings business was originally owned by a Mrs D Norris who has now left and I Paul Mather am once again running this side of the business I apologise for any bad experience you received and hope now that the staff have changed we can assist you in the future all the best Paul Mather

1/5

Google

THE WORST!! DON'T EVEN BOTHER WALKING IN THERE ESPECIALLY IF YOU'RE AN INEXPERIENCED STUDENT!! I shouldn't have even bothered given them a star at all!

London · 26 June 2014 · Mather Marshall

1/5

Google

THE WORST!! DON'T EVEN BOTHER WALKING IN THERE ESPECIALLY IF YOU'RE AN INEXPERIENCED STUDENT!! I shouldn't have even bothered given them a star at all!

Lez · 1 May 2014 · Mather Marshall

A review that appears on several offices' pages is shown once. We leave out reviews that name another agent.

Questions about Mather Marshall

How many reviews does Mather Marshall have?

Mather Marshall has 581 reviews across its three offices, rated 4.5 out of 5 overall: 418 on Google, 31 on Facebook, 129 on View Agents, 3 on Trustpilot. A review that appears on several offices' pages, such as the company's Trustpilot, is counted once. Checked 9 October 2026.

Which Mather Marshall office has the most reviews?

Mather Marshall has the most, with 307 reviews rated 4.3 out of 5, followed by Mather Marshall with 148.

Where are Mather Marshall's offices?

Mather Marshall, 129 High Street, Old Town SG1 3HS; Mather Marshall, 27 Market Place AL10 0LJ; Mather Marshall Estate Agents Knebworth, 132 London Road SG3 6EY.

What do sellers say about Mather Marshall?

45 reviews from sellers, rated 4.9 out of 5 on average. For example, Mark wrote: "Darren is The Best Estate Agent in Knebworth!!  he sold our house in a week to the second person that viewed it, the marketing was spot on and a cut above the ..."

What do buyers say about Mather Marshall?

38 reviews from buyers, rated 4.9 out of 5 on average. For example, Joanne wrote: "We recently purchased a house and Darren went above and beyond to help us during this time. Open honest communication in a timely manner with regular updates as ..."

What do tenants say about Mather Marshall?

3 reviews from tenants, rated 3.7 out of 5 on average. For example, Megan wrote: "I have been looking for a property and been shocked by the awful 'beside' manner of some of the letting agents. Thankfully after finding a property I liked ..."

The Trusted Agent

Ratings and review counts checked 9 October 2026. Is this your office? Claim your page.