Trusted Agent profile

Haybrook reviews

★★★★★ Excellent

733 reviews across 3 platforms

9-11 Middlewood Road, Hillsborough, Sheffield S6 4GU

Haybrook's Sheffield office at 9-11 Middlewood Road is rated 4.5 out of 5 across 733 reviews on three platforms, including 450 Google reviews rated 4.9. It won Platinum in The Trusted Agent 2026 awards. Checked 9 October 2026.

Google logo

4.9 / 5

450

Reviews on Google

This office

Yell logo

5.0 / 5

1

Reviews on Yell

This office

Trustpilot logo

282

Reviews on Trustpilot

This office

Reviews may appear on more than one platform.

Awards

Trusted Agent 2026 results for Haybrook. Each award is assessed separately from the review sites.

Reviews

Every review we hold for the Sheffield office, from every platform, shown as written. First names only.

5/5

Google

We were delighted with the service we received after requesting a valuation of our unusual property. Yvonne was personable, professional and punctual. Not only did she send us a comprehensive report as requested but her intensive knowledge of the area and how it has changed in recent years shone through. We would have no hesitation in using Haybrook at Hillsborough for our future property needs.

Helen · 22 June 2023

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Thank you so much for your kind words Helen, It was was a delight meeting you both its not very often I have the privilege of valuing a unique property such as yours.

5/5

Google

Cannot recommend Lola enough! She helped us with purchasing our dream home. Even when the sale of our apartment took a few months longer than we expected, she was there every step of the way, very understanding and communicating with us and the seller of the house. She made it all stress free for us and can’t thank her enough!

Elizabeth · 25 September 2023

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Thank you for your kind words.. it was our pleasure to assist you in your property search, and eventually find your dream home through to completion. we wish you all the best in the future.

5/5

Google

Just want to say a huge thank you to the team at haybrooks for all there amazing work from start to finish of the sale of my house.. Joanne Calvert has been absolutely brilliant throughout. Always there to answer any queries or worries by text or phone and constantly keeping me upto date..My sale was a testing one what with solicitors problems and covid playing its part but the team were always on hand to help. Linda was amazing at marketing and getting me a quick sale also mandy on the days Jo wasnt around. Thank you everyone. I got my dream home and moved in by Christmas and a lovely buyer now has my property. Win win situation . Couldnt have done it without youPositiveResponsiveness, Quality, Professionalism

Natalie · 22 June 2021

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Thank you Natalie for your lovely review, it was a pleasure helping you move and we wish you all the best in your new home, thanks again, Mandy

5/5

Google

Top class service from Ella and their in house independent mortgage advisor Rob, who both were outstandingly helpful while dealing with my first property purchase. Couldn't have asked for more from them. Many thanks once again!

Matthew · 11 April 2026

Agent replied · 16 April 2026

Thank you Matthew, all the best in your new home !

5/5

Google

We received outstanding service from the whole team at Haybrooks. Yvonne, Lola and George went the extra mile to ensure our sale was dealt with professionally. George was exceptionnel at liaising between us, solicitors the buyers and keeping everyone informed. Thanks everyone.. I can't thank you enough!

Liz · 22 May 2024

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Thank you so much for your kind words!

5/5

Google

Thank to Haybrook and specially thanks to George how helped me to find a good house. He is a lovely man and helping nature. I will be thankful if he guided me throughout the process. Thanks George ✌️

Sunil · 26 September 2024

Agent replied · 26 October 2024

Thank you for your kind review Sunil! We look forward to helping you throughout the process.

5/5

Google

From the very beginning Lola was fantastic with my house purchase, highly recommended, sale went through in no time at all! I had some minor issues after the sale with the house which she phoned me to help and even took her time to explain to me how to open my patio door! best estate agent Iv used in Sheffield

Beau · 22 June 2023

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Many thanks for your lovely comments and review

1/5

Trustpilot

Dreadful experience

Our experience with Haybrook Crystal Peaks was extremely disappointing.

Anna · 16 June 2026

5/5

Google

We have had a brilliant experience putting our house on the market with Haybrooks. Everything was perfect, with well coordinated viewings and great communication - all provided by the very exceptional George Vaughton! Many thanks for all your work, help and advice, George!

Angela · 28 June 2024

Agent replied · 26 October 2024

Thank you so much for your review!

5/5

Google

So grateful to the Haybrooks team for their help with my sale. Joanne was brilliant and a pleasure to liaise with from start to finish. She was impressively responsive and went above and beyond to help keep everything moving and make sure communication flowed. Thrilled to have had her overseeing my sale, but the whole team deserve a shout out as everyone who I spoke to was friendly and helpful!

Zoë · 22 June 2022

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

thank you for your lovely words Zoe, it's ben a pleasure dealing with you and your purchase

5/5

Google

I had a very good experience with this company and George Vaughton has been especially kind and helpful. I am very grateful to him for his service, dedication to his craft and his passion to answer my questions accurately.

Emmanuela · 27 August 2024

Agent replied · 26 October 2024

Thanks! We looking forward to continuing to assist you in finding your dream home!

5/5

Google

I live in Derby so much of my contact with Haybrook Hillsborough has been on the phone and Susan Smyth has always made herself available. However, I have driven to see the flat in Regent Court twice. Once on my own and once with my son. Susan Smyth has ensured she is available to allow me to view the flat. Susan has even taken the time to show me around the centre of Hillsborough, pointing out shops, facilities and amenities, having listened carefully to my requirements. If I have had queries Susan has been able to answer them immediately. If not knowing the answer, she has researched it and returned to me promptly. I have no hesitation in recommending Haybrook to any potential buyer and would recommend Susan Smyth as a consultant. Tess Boswell

Tess · 22 June 2020

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Hi Tess ,thank you for the 5 star review we strive for 100% satisfaction, and it is great to see you had such a positive experience at Haybrook Hillsborough. We always love to hear from our customers, especially with such great feedback. We wish you all the best and we are here to guide you every step of the way. Thanks again Haybrook Hillsborough

5/5

Google

From the moment we walked in we felt welcomed by all the staff members and it was a pleasure to deal with each and every one of them. I would like to give a special mention to Susan Smyth who dealt with our offer from start to finish and was always on hand to answer any questions regarding the process of buying a house. I highly recommend going in and asking for help wether you are a first time buyer or just looking to change from your existing property.

James · 22 June 2020

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Dear James Turner, Thank you for leaving such great and detailed feedback about your experience with ourselves , we are over the moon to hear we have delivered a 5 star service Best wishes Hillsborough Haybrook

5/5

Google

Never sold a property before, I was very nervous about doing so, because I was selling on behalf of my very dear soulmate and didn't want to make mistakes. I needn't have worried, from entering Haybrooks Hillsborough I was put at my ease. Linda came to the property and explained clearly in a language I could understand the process. Returned to take excellent photos. From then on the team, Linda, Jo, Sue, Mandy and Helen kept me continually updated on the sale. I can't thank Haybrooks Hillsborough enough, absolute excellent service. Everything organised for us, from finding a solicitor to organising someone to complete an energy efficiency certificate. I will conclude by saying I will certainly be recommending Haybrooks Hillsborough to anyone buying or selling.

KIM · 22 June 2020

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Hi Kim Thank you so much for your lovely comments. We are so pleased you've had a positive experience selling your dear friends property. Its been a pleasure working with you and we wish you all the best. Thanks again The Hillsborough Team

5/5

Google

We have just completed the sale of my mothers property and from the very beginning everything has been handled with an incredibly professional and personal approach we couldn't be happier. We chose haybrooks as looking at what we wanted, taking into consideration my mothers age her personal attatchement to our family home and the fact that this was something she'd never done before we needed the handling to be perfect. We were visited by linda who started the process, taking the most amazing photo's showcasing my mothers home like a true professional. She was attentive, thoughtful and genuinely understood our needs and concerns. This started the process with an open house, this was on the 27th April, by the end of the following week we had an offer on the table, due to showing some concerns I had raised direct to the branch we were visited by Mandy the branch manager who explained the process,reasurred us and promised that her team would guide and support us through the process right to the very end. Over the next several weeks we were updated weekly any queries answered immediately and concerns quashed. We were personally guided through the process by helen who i can honestly say makes it her mission to deliver on everything promised. From the initial acceptance of the offer to the completion of the sale the process took 7 weeks which is incredible this was helped by using the branches recognised solicitor Faye who works hand in hand with the branch, team and sellers supporting a very professional service. As a family we can't thankyou enough there was a clear personal touch from each member of the team who work incredibly well together including each of the sales people in the office in order to deliver . It was faultless, a service that gives you what it promises and much more. Thankyou to the team and special thanks to Helen, Mandy and Linda. Maxine, dot and family

Maxine · 22 June 2020

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Hi Maxine , thank you so much for taking the time to give feedback we are delighted we have achieved such a positive outcome for Dot and the service levels we delivered met all your expectations from beginning to end , we send our best wishes and regards to you all and hope Dot will be happy in her new home Kind Regards Hillsborough Haybrook

5/5

Google

We have to say the biggest of thank you’s for the incredible service we have received from all of the team at Haybrooks, Hillsborough! We would particularly like to thank Linda, who was the first person we met at the beginning of this process. She is an absolute breath of fresh air and explained everything so well about selling our home! We would also like to say a really, really big thank you to Helen who has been such a fantastic support throughout! She has been so warm and kind and kept us updated constantly. She has quite literally been our rock and has worked so hard to make sure everything has gone well! We just couldn’t have done this without her! We would also like to give Mandy a special mention who at the eleventh hour quite literally went above and beyond for us! She is a super hero in disguise and what she did for us was just amazing! Thank you so much! We wouldn’t hesitate in recommending Haybrooks Estate Agents! It has been an emotional time for us and you have been there every step of the way! Thank you so much, we wish you all the best! Susan, Tracy and Amy xxx

Amy · 22 June 2020

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Hi Amy , we would like express our thanks for the wonderful feedback , we are delighted that you have had such a positive experience , and we have helped to make such an emotional time easier for you all , we would like to send our very best wishes and to add you have been a pleasure to deal with kind Regards Mandy and the Team at Hillsborough Haybrook

5/5

Google

Mandy and Helen were brilliant in helping us move to our lovely new home. They responded well when I was impatient and met all their commitments ..... keeping me informed all the way through a pretty trying series of events Helen was always bright and helpful Mandy brought calm and kept me going/sane as things became fraught Thank you both ....and for your smooth liaison with Jack at banner cross branch. This really is such a lovely house/ location with autumn colours and sunlight streaming in, the garden!!!!!! And the general location Thanks for your help and for perseverance with us All the best for the future Andy n Kate Overton

Andy · 22 June 2020

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Hi Andy, thank you so much for your lovely words and positive feedback, we are so happy you love your new home we think its fab too All the very Best Mandy and the Team

5/5

Google

As a first time buyers, Susan Smyth was very helpful and made the process of buying our first home really straightforward. She is very knowledgable about the local area and gave good advice when asked. She was very accommodating and proactive. She worked around our schedules and had a good understanding of what we needed in a property. Really happy with her services! I would highly recommend them to my friends and family! All the best to you Susan and the whole team at Haybrook Hillborough

Hazel · 22 June 2020

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Dear Happy Gal, Thank you for taking the time to leave us feedback. We are very pleased to hear about your experience with us whilst purchasing your new property. We can't wait to see you again, have a great day. Hillsborough Haybrook

5/5

Google

We've been delighted to experience the purchase of our new home recently from Haybrook in Hillsborough. Amazing customer service and I cannot thank enough Susan Smyth who has always been helpful to show us the property and make us see the potential in it. Susan Smyth is an excellent real estate agent with a wonderful personality, willing to go the extra mile to help! Looking forward to the exchange of contracts now but thanks to Susan we are able to view the property again and start making plans for our dream home.

Elena · 22 June 2020

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Hi Elena We're really happy you found Sue to be so supportive during your experience here at Haybrook Hillsborough. Thank you for your lovely comments

5/5

Google

I had the pleasure of meeting Sue Smyth while I was looking for a house in Hillsborough. She was immediately warm and friendly as I walked into the estate agency and put me at ease straight away. I really loved that she took the time to get to know me as a person and build a rapport with me. Even taking the time to write down all my requirements on paper face to face rather than from behind a computer screen. Simply put, Sue was brilliant! I can’t recommend her any more highly. Honestly it was it was the best service I have received from any estate agent. So far away from the usual uncaring and eager to get a quick sale mentality. Now that my requirements have changed in sad that Sue can’t help me look for a place in my new home town. Thanks Sue for your time and efforts, it was really appreciated and great to meet you. And to anyone looking to buy a house in the Sheffield/Hillsborough area go and speak to Sue.... you won’t be disappointed!

Rich · 22 June 2020

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Hi Rich , thank you for your feedback we are please to read that you have had such a positive experience with Sue , and felt that your received such great customer experience from Hillsborough Haybrook we wish you all the best for the future and please contact us anytime if we can be of any assistance Regards Hillsborough Haybrook

5/5

Google

We used this company to sell our house and found them efficient, professional and friendly from the very start. Both me and my wife found the staff very helpful and professional particularly Linda from the very start who was absolutely brilliant in preparing our house for sale and Helen who always kept us up to date throughout the whole process. We would definitely recommend this company and would definitely use them again to sell future properties. Thank you very much.

Justin · 22 June 2020

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Dear Justin Homyard, Thank you for taking the time to leave us feedback. We are delighted you are pleased with the service you received whilst selling your property. Thank you again for your star rating! Regards Haybrook Hillsborough

5/5

Google

I contacted Haybrook Hillsborough Branch in June 2019 as I had the unenviable task of trying to convince my parents to downsize after 52 years at the same address! Linda came to visit my parents and immediately picked up the barriers I was struggling with and very carefully managed to convince them, that it wasn't an impossible move and that people would be there to help them. Linda even took it upon herself to delivery flyers to addresses in the area to houses that met my parents very specific criteria! In September they took the step to market and have an open house event, which took the pressure off my parents to do viewings. From here Jo took over and kept me updated as I requested with viewings book and background information. Unfortunately the open day was on the wettest day of the year and many roads were closed due to flooding, but Jo made her way through and successfully held the event. We were updated with offers from the Monday morning onwards and all potential buyers were informed again as requested that my parents still needed to find somewhere and should not be rushed. We had to have further viewing due the weather and the office staff all worked together to ensure minimum disruption to my parents. Sue and Helen also put themselves out to accommodate viewings. My father became ill during November and I spoke to Mandy who immediately agreed to stop further viewing and inform all concerned that things would go on hold until the new year. As promised this happen and things move ahead again in the new year, with a sale negotiated & agreed and a purchase agreed. We decided to use Haybrook Legal Team as we were advised that the branch could help process all the paperwork, which they did. Jo staying late to complete and send off the necessary paperwork. The sale/purchase is not complete yet but as for the service so far, it is second to none, taking the pressure off me, even when it was to let off some steam when my parents were being a little awkward! Yes I would highly recommend and hope this review helps.

Jo · 22 June 2020

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Hi Joanne , thank you so much for the detailed feedback and 5 star review you have given the team at Hillsborough, we are delighted that you have received such a positive service and even more that you would recommend ourselves We are here to assist you every step of the way Regards Hillsborough Haybrook

5/5

Google

Haybrooks fees were a little higher than we expected but true to their word - they certainly go that extra mile for their money! Linda was super keen to call round and get a 'feel' for the property and soon came back to take some great photos (she even brought two of the team from the office to be introduced!). Sue and Jo were well organised with viewings between them, giving us complete faith that our property would soon be sold. I dealt with Sue mainly, her communication was faultless, keeping us in the loop at all times, every step of the way. What a professional team, there is no doubt in my mind that Mandy and Helen will complete the sale just as competently as this company certainly know how to give their customers a five star service! Keep up the fantastic work Haybrooks!! :-) x

Angie · 22 June 2020

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Hi Angie , we are over the moon to hear you have had a brilliant experience from the team , we pride ourselves on delivering 100% customer service and pleased to see we have achieved this , we will continue to assist you every step of the way Best Wishes Hillsborough Haybrook

5/5

Google

As a first timer buyer, I was very nervous and didn’t know what to expect. I was extremely happy with their excellent costumer service throughout the whole process. Joanne Calvert was always on hand to show me around the property and answer any question I had. Helen Dyson was amazing at keeping me informed at each stage and made sure completion happened on time. Thank you for all your support and help in making the process smooth. I would definitely recommend Haybrook Hillsborough.

Gemz · 22 June 2020

Agent replied · 21 June 2024

Hi Gemma ,Thank you for taking the time to give feedback , pleased to hear you have received such a positive experience and were kept informed throughout , we are over the moon that we have delivered a 5 star service for you and wish you lots of happiness in your new home Have a great day Hillsborough Haybrook

Where the same review appears twice we show it once. We leave out reviews that name another agent or another of the brand's offices.

Read Haybrook's Google reviews

Questions about Haybrook

How many reviews does Haybrook have?

Haybrook's Sheffield office has 733 reviews across three platforms: 450 on Google, 1 on Yell, 282 on Trustpilot. Reviews may appear on more than one platform. Checked 9 October 2026.

What is Haybrook's rating?

Haybrook is rated 4.5 out of 5 across all 733 reviews, and 4.9 out of 5 on Google from 450 reviews, checked 9 October 2026.

Has Haybrook won any awards?

Yes. In The Trusted Agent 2026 awards: Haybrook, Sheffield won Platinum.

Where is Haybrook's Sheffield office?

Haybrook, 9-11 Middlewood Road, Hillsborough, Sheffield S6 4GU.

The Trusted Agent

Ratings and review counts checked 9 October 2026. Is this your office? Claim your page.