Trusted Agent profile Β· Sheffield

Haybrook Sheffield reviews

β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜… Excellent

771 reviews across 3 platforms

9-11 Middlewood Road, Hillsborough, Sheffield, S6 4GU

Haybrook's office in Sheffield, at 9-11 Middlewood Road, is rated 4.6 out of 5 across 771 reviews on three platforms, including 489 Google reviews rated 4.9. It won Platinum in The Trusted Agent 2026 awards.

Google logo

4.9 / 5

489

Reviews on Google

This office

Yell logo

5.0 / 5

1

Reviews on Yell

This office

Trustpilot logo

281

Reviews on Trustpilot

This office

Reviews may appear on more than one platform.

Awards

The Trusted Agent 2026 results for Haybrook, ranked against 18,569 UK estate agent offices. Each award is assessed separately from the review sites.

Reviews

Every review we hold for the Sheffield office, from every platform, shown as written. First names only.

1/5

Trustpilot

Unprofessional

I received a letter from haybrook gleadless branch in Sheffield saying if you are interested in moving home book an appointment with us so we can value your home and talk you through the steps of moving. We are wanting to move into a bigger home now we have children so my wife booked a day off work because they could only get Wednesday mid day. 6pm the day before we get a phone call saying theres been a double booking we need to reschedule...we was slightly annoyed with booking time off work but thought it happens so had to arrange again for a couple of weeks later..That morning two hours before the appointment they phone goes again sorry we need to reschedule...it is very unprofessional I will never use this company again. They obviously think people can waste time and money never again

Dane Β· 13 August 2021

Agent replied Β· 19 June 2024

Hi,We're sorry to hear about your situation. This isn't the five star level of service we strive for. If you'd like to discuss this further, please email help@haybrook.com with details and we will pass to the relevant team to assist you.Thank you

5/5

Google

Linda came to value my property and was a fantastic help. I'd definitely recommend. Linda was very knowledgeable about the area, the market and was able to offer general advice on the process. As a first time seller this was invaluable.

S Β· 23 June 2018

Agent replied Β· 21 June 2024

We are always more than happy to assist you if anything else comes up. Take care! Thank you for the great review!

5/5

Google

Fantastic experience working with Haybrooks. Very helpful, friendly staff who are never too busy to help. Great communication, very professional and hardworking. A special thanks to Sue, Helen and Sophie your a credit to your company. All the best. Mat Birks.

Bee Β· 23 June 2018

Agent replied Β· 21 June 2024

Dear Mathew Briks, Thank you for taking the time to leave us feedback. We are very pleased to hear about your experience with us whilst purchasing your new property. Please don't hesitate to reach out if there's anything additional we can do for you.

5/5

Trustpilot

Brilliant for property management & sales

Sincere thanks to Katie and the letting team who have done a fantastic job of managing my property over the last five years whilst I have been overseas. There was also a seamless transition to Kenneth and the sales team for the recent completion, which again was all managed remotely and they found me a buyer within a couple of days. 100% recommended for both property management and sales.

Michael Β· 13 May 2020

5/5

Google

Recently completed the purchase of my property through Haybrooks. Lola showed me around the property and was involved throughout the purchase process, negotiating with the sellers and chasing up loose ends. It felt like Lola made the service bespoke to me and my circumstances. Very polite, professional and responsive- you couldn’t ask for a nicer estate agent.PositiveResponsiveness, Professionalism

Cjhickin Β· 22 June 2022

5/5

Google

Really excellent long term service for helping my elderly mother buy per apartment from vendors selling through Haybrooks Hillsborough. You can only tell the quality of the team when something goes wrong and there are difficulties. Sue and the team went out of their way to help throughout, ironing out the wrinkles all the way and my mam is now happily in the flat thanks to this teams dedication. Thank you.

Latebustuesday Β· 23 June 2019

5/5

Trustpilot

Many thanks to the Team!

First experiences can be very stressful, but with the Haybrook team, it was easier than I expectedSteven was our Man, alongwith Nicola and Sharon are a very nice and approachable team, with advice, quick response to both emails and phone calls. Thank you very much !

Home Β· 11 July 2024

Agent replied Β· 23 August 2024

Many thanks for your kind words.

5/5

Google

What a fantastic set of ladies! It’s been a pleasure from start to finish! As soon as I met Linda I knew she was the one to sell my house! She was so welcoming, friendly and knowledgable. Nothing was too much trouble! She answered all of my questions and made what I thought was going to be a stressful time so straight forward! Job well done Linda! Jo and Helen have been amazing at keeping us up to date on viewings and progress of the sale! Can’t rate them enough πŸ˜€

Lauren Β· 22 June 2021

Agent replied Β· 21 June 2024

Hi Lauren thank you for the 5 star feedback we are so pleased to hear you have had such a great experience for Hillsborough Haybrook and chose us based on your impressions of the team and what they have delivered for you, we will continue to help and support you every step of the way have a great day Hillsborough Haybrook

5/5

Google

The Haybrook Hillsborough Team have been excellent throughout my recent house sale, from the initial valuation and viewings through to final completion. Jo Calvert dealt with the sale and from the very beginning she has been quick to respond by both telephone and email. She has continually kept me updated throughout lockdown too. Jo is very experienced, professional, helpful, patient and so friendly. Thank you to Jo and the whole team for dealing with the sale so sensitively. I recommend them 100%. Thank you once again.PositiveResponsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value

Andrea Β· 22 June 2021

Agent replied Β· 21 June 2024

Hi Andrea, thank you very much for your feedback, it's been a pleasure dealing with you, kind regards, Haybrook

5/5

Google

I met Linda at my valuation, what a lovely, pleasant, helpful lady, Linda is.Made my experience simple , she has taken all the stress and worries that I had away. Can’t fault Haybrook . Highly recommend.

Marilyn Β· 22 June 2020

Agent replied Β· 21 June 2024

Hi Marilyn, thank you for the feedback regarding Linda we are so pleased that you have had a great experience with us and we have delivered a 5 star service to you Regards Hillsborough Haybrook

5/5

Trustpilot

Fantastic service from Bianca

I cannot recommend the service enough. Professional friendly and reliable. Bianca was fantastic and listened to all my concerns. I'll certainly be recommending your service and will use your business for any future needs.

Ian Β· 16 April 2024

1/5

Trustpilot

No stars

Shame there isn't an option for no stars. No communication or even worse the wrong information give time and time sgain. Calls unanswered, un returned, emails never replied too. Very unprofessional emails recieved. Cannot understand how such a big company can get away with such shocking service. Will never deal with them again. Been so stressful trying to sort anything out I feel sorry for tenants and landlords being made to look bad through haybrook poor service

Jay Β· 16 July 2024

1/5

Google

Please do not use this agency, they do not value the landlords and they just charge you for management fees but they don’t provide any service. Their website also not correct as many as their staff have left the company and they are irresponsible through out the service

Mo Β· 22 May 2024

Agent replied Β· 21 June 2024

Thank you for your feedback. We are sorry to hear about your recent experience with the letting department. I understand your frustration and i want to assure you that we take all feedback seriously. However please note the here at Haybrook Hillsborough we do not have a lettings department this is a separate branch for the whole of Sheffield which is situated in the centre of Sheffield. I will make sure to forward your concerns to the appropriate team so they can address the issue promptly. If there is anything else we can assist you at our branch, please do not hesitate to reach out. Your satisfaction is important to us and we are here to help. Best regard Yvonne

1/5

Trustpilot

Do not let your property out with this…

Do not let your property out with this company at any cost. They are horrendous through and through. An unprofessional money making mickey mouse company who do absolutely nothing for the huge amount of money they take from you every month.Unprofessional to say the least in more ways than one. Manager - Sharon ringing up at 10.00pm on a Sunday evening to discuss a contract??? Thought this was perfectly acceptable conduct. Stated she had a spare minute so thought it appropriate to call our home. Office staff never answer phone calls despite message after message being left. I would rather leave my property empty than deal with this joke of a letting agent. Please folks take my advice and don't let your property out with these money sharks. They are rubbish in every which way possible.

Gail Β· 22 May 2024

5/5

Google

Although I didn't buy a house through Haybrook, they were really helpful in organising viewings in an area I was unfamiliar with and Susan was particularly adept at sending me the details of appropriate properties and maintaining contact.

Andrew Β· 23 June 2019

Agent replied Β· 21 June 2024

Andrew Johnstone, we are glad we could help! Hillsborough Haybrook

4/5

Google

We had a few problems initially, but once we were assigned Helen Dyson as our contact, she kept us informed right through the process, with regular updates and news on the sale. Helen was professional at all times.

Michelle Β· 23 June 2019

Agent replied Β· 21 June 2024

Hi Michelle thank you for your review , happy to see you were informed throughout. Regards Hillsborough Haybrook

5/5

Trustpilot

Thank-you Daniel

Daniel Scott has been extremely professional, I have been kept upto date throughout. I have had no reason to chase things up and the process has been stress free. Daniel has been super efficient, thank you x

Denise Β· 12 August 2019

Agent replied Β· 19 June 2024

Denise Tracey, we are so happy to read such a great review about Haybrook Sheffield (Lettings)! We're glad to hear we delivered such a great experience. If there's anything further we can do for you, we are happy to help!

1/5

Trustpilot

Absolutely terrible company

Absolutely terrible company. Echoing the reviews below, they never reply to emails. You can never get hold of them via the phone. They are meant to manage our property, but they don’t. We can never speak to them, as there is never any way to contact them. They are completely inept and thoroughly disappointing. The only consistency they have is that they are consistently lax. Please avoid this company at all costs. I wish we had

Vicky Β· 5 July 2024

5/5

Google

George Vaughton has helped make the buying process a lot less stressful than it might have been. He is always positive and is very efficient. He replies to emails and phone calls very quickly and always does what he says he is going to do in good time.

Jonathan Β· 22 April 2024

Agent replied Β· 21 June 2024

Thank you for your kind words!

5/5

Google

My property has sold in record time the staff listened to my requirements and have kept me informed at every step very efficient and caring could not be more pleased with the service highly recommend Hillsborough branch sheffield

Carole Β· 23 June 2018

Agent replied Β· 21 June 2024

Thank you for taking the time to leave us feedback. We are delighted you are pleased with the service you received whilst selling your property. Have a fantastic day!

5/5

Google

Ella was a amazing help

Top Β· 19 May 2025

5/5

Google

Helen, Helen, Helen!!! An absolute diamond and an assette to Haybrooks. We accepted an offer on our home back in August and we are just about to exchange contracts today and complete next Friday. Since accepting the offer Helen has continuously chased up paperwork and solicitors and kept us updated every step of the way. Its pretty stressful selling a house and can be a prolonged experience but Helen, thank you for everything and I'm hoping I get to call in and meet you face to face and to say thank you personally. xx

Debbie Β· 22 June 2020

Agent replied Β· 21 June 2024

Hi Debbie , thank you so much for the brilliant feedback and your kind comments regarding the service you have received from Helen we look forward to seeing you when you pop into the branch soon Best Wishes Haybrook

5/5

Google

I can’t praise Sue Smyth and the Haybrook team in Hillsborough enough. They are so helpful. I’ve view many properties with Sue and she can’t do enough to help me, As a single parent I don’t have a lot of time but I feel she accommodate my needs and requirements and is dedicated to helping me find my perfect family home. So much so that when I’ve looked around properties she’s very kindly played with my son to enable me to have a proper look. She response to all my emails quickly and is happy to answer any of questions big or small. Thank you so for Sue for making buying my first home a lot less stressful.

Eleanor Β· 22 June 2020

Agent replied Β· 21 June 2024

Dear Eleanor Morrison, Thank you for leaving such great and detailed feedback about your experience with Haybrook Hillsborough estate agents, and we added that personal touch Have a great day Hillsborough Haybrook

5/5

Google

Recently purchased a house via haybrookes hillsborough, assisted by Joanne Calvert and Helen Dyson. Absolutely fantastic customer service from day one. They regularly chased my solicitor, vendors solicitor and gave me regular updates to ensure sale progressed in an efficient way. Very knowledgeable and able to answer any questions I had. They were able to help me troubleshoot last minute issues to ensure the desired completion date could be met. I would not hesitate to use their very professional and honest services.

S Β· 22 June 2020

Agent replied Β· 21 June 2024

Hi Sam Thank you for taking the time to leave us this lovely feedback. We are very pleased to hear about your experience with us whilst purchasing your new property. From the Hillsborough Team

Where the same review appears twice we show it once. We leave out reviews that name another agent or another of the brand's offices.

Read Haybrook's Google reviewsLeave Haybrook a review

Questions about Haybrook Sheffield

Has Haybrook won any awards?

Yes. In The Trusted Agent 2026 awards: Haybrook, Sheffield won Platinum.

The Trusted Agent

Is this your office? Claim your page.