Trusted Agent profile · Penistone

Simon Blyth Penistone reviews

4.5

★★★★★ Excellent

141 reviews across 2 platforms

1a St. Marys Street, Penistone, S36 6DT

Simon Blyth's office in Penistone, at 1a St. Marys Street, is rated 4.5 out of 5 across 141 reviews on two platforms, including 103 Google reviews rated 4.8.

Google logo

4.8 / 5

103

Reviews on Google

This office

Trustpilot logo

38

Reviews on Trustpilot

Business-wide

Reviews may appear on more than one platform.

Reviews

Every review we hold for the Penistone office, from every platform, shown as written. First names only.

4/5

Google

Although the initial value of our property was probably too high, which would seem to be the norm for this company, we did eventually sell for considerably lower price. However, Charlotte and Maria at the Penistone office were very helpful and kept us well informed throughout the process, I can't thank them enough.

Richard · 16 April 2025

5/5

Google

Simon Blyth in Penistone have been fantastic. They helped identify a property that matched our needs; the service from searching through to purchase and moving has been very personal, professional and effective. I fully recommend their services.

Nick · 25 August 2024

Agent replied · 24 October 2024

Thank you so much for your fantastic review Nick! It was a pleasure to help you and your family find your new home. We hope you are all very happy here! All the best! Maria & Charlotte

5/5

Google

We recently had to sell a relative's house and Maria was wonderfully helpful at following up with all parties to make the process as smooth as possible. As we are some distance from Penistone it was reassuring to have someone help to arrange gardeners and the house clearance for us as well- we would certainly recommend Simon Blyth in Penistone to anyone. Many thanks!

Richard · 17 June 2019

5/5

Google

We have recently bought our property through Simon Blyth, Maria and her team made the process as pain free as possible with clear, professional and helpful advice and information.

Rachel · 16 June 2020

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you so much for your feedback Rachel :)

5/5

Google

The team at Simon Blyth were excellent, really responsive and supportive at all times. David gave us great advice, and Maria Diaz was incredibly helpful, friendly and exceptionally professional. The service we received was superb! We bought and sold through Simon Blyth and would highly recommend them! A huge thank you to Maria and the team!PositiveProfessionalism

David · 16 June 2021

5/5

Google

We recently used Simon Blythe to sell our home and cannot fault the service we received. Our house was marketed well and we achieved a sale quickly. Maria was incredibly helpful throughout the process and kept us well informed. She frequently made contact with all parties involved in the chain to ensure the sale proceeded as smoothly as possible. Highly recommend.

Joanne · 17 June 2019

5/5

Trustpilot

Halifax Office

I want to give a big thank you to Alex and Lesley at the Halifax office for giving me support and guidance when I was struggling to sell my property, and then chasing solicitors etc to get the sale over the line! The sale took many months and they showed great tenacity in progressing things and keeping me informed. Really fabulous service!

Allie · 26 October 2017

5/5

Google

Simon Blyth in Penistone and particularly Maria were fantastic in helping me sell my bungalow, they went above and beyond in marketing my property and kept me informed at every step of the way - they did all the viewing for me and when it sold they liaised with both parties solicitors making it a stress free experience

Stuart · 17 June 2019

5/5

Google

We received excellent service from Scott at the Penistone branch. He was most pleasant and professional at the same time. Unfortunately we were unable to find a suitable property from him but would most certainly recommend him to prospective buyers. PAUL and Jennie Thackray

Paul · 14 April 2025

5/5

Google

All the staff at Simon Blyth Penistone office worked so hard to sell a house for us, it was quite unbelievable. As soon as the house went on the market it was as though we had our own agent, constant phone calls, e-mails etc with bookings and updates. The staff filtered the appointments to our requirements, we did the viewings just short of 20 one weekend and the team did the rest. Thank you to everyone at the Penistone office for making this difficult experience so easy. from the first day when the house was valued to the day the house sale contracts were exchanged the team kept us informed at all times. Well done.

Peter · 16 June 2023

5/5

Google

First class service from all the staff in the Penistone office,professional, friendly and helpful, kept me well informed throughout the whole process. Would definitely recommend this estate agents and if ever we need to sell or buy again Simon Blyths will be top of the list.

John · 16 June 2023

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you so much John for your kind words and amazing review to our business. We look forward to working for you again soon! All the best!

5/5

Google

I sold my property through Simon Blyth's Penistone branch and was delighted with their service - they excelled! I had multiple offers securing the sale on the first day of listing. Maria and Charlotte ensured everything was taken care of, …

Robert · 16 April 2025

1/5

Trustpilot

Phoned the Barnsley Branch to make an…

Phoned the Barnsley Branch to make an appointment for my property to be valued. Explained that I work and would it be possible to value at some point. Heard nothing back at all!!! I find it RUDE and it’s only CURTIOUS to phone back to say yes or no. Clearly Simon Blythe doesn’t want business so I’ll spend my money elsewhere !!!!

Philip · 17 May 2024

5/5

Google

I would just like to say thank you to the Penistone team for being so supportive and helpful when me and my husband had such a stressful time selling our house. I was very greatful for the support received particularly by Maria and Kristy . They really tried their best to make a very stressful time for us more manageable. Thank you. Jack and Lucy

Lucy · 16 June 2020

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you so much Lucy and Jack! We truly appreciate your comments :)

1/5

Trustpilot

Rejected for no reason 🙃

Rejected for no reason 🙃 I don't recommend!

Dragos-Gabriel · 6 March 2025

Agent replied · 24 September 2026

We're sorry that you have felt the need to leave a one-star review. Please could you send more information?

5/5

Trustpilot

Asking price for my property in 6 weeks

SB got me asking price for my property in 6 weeks. The service was excellent and the staff could not have been friendlier or more helpful.

Sandra · 15 August 2025

5/5

Google

A very professional estate agent. We have experience of dealing with them when both buying and selling. They follow up, chase solicitors, keep both parties in touch and are unfailingly polite and helpful. We would definitely use them again.

Liz · 16 June 2023

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you sooo much Liz and Alan! It was an absolute pleasure to work for you both. All our best wishes from Simon Blyth Penistone team.

1/5

Trustpilot

Rang to view a property 6 days ago…

Rang to view a property 6 days ago haven’t heard anything back. Would never sell through them.

Vivek · 20 September 2024

Agent replied · 24 September 2026

We're sorry that you have felt the need to leave a one-star review. Please could you send more information?

5/5

Google

Great Team. Very professional.

Nicholas · 22 March 2025

Agent replied · 16 April 2026

Thank you Nick :)

5/5

Google

Writing on behalf of my mum: Over a long period of time, with difficult house buyers, a difficult house to sell and at a testing time of family loss, Maria Diaz (residential sales negotiator at Penistone office) was truly amazing and helped sell our property. She was professional, patient and an all round star. We can't thank her enough!

Amy · 16 June 2020

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you so much Amy and Caroline!

5/5

Trustpilot

Stacey and the team at the Barnsley…

Stacey and the team at the Barnsley office have been great throughout the process of selling my home and even helped me find my next home! Thanks again, would 100% use again.

John · 16 June 2022

5/5

Google

Great to deal with from start to finish. Provided the level of service you hope to get. I would 100% use them again in the future. Thank you Kristy and Maria for making this purchase as easy as possible.PositiveResponsiveness, Professionalism

A · 25 October 2020

5/5

Google

Maria and the team were fantastic during our recent house move. They were in touch regularly with updates and remained impartial in all areas. We had a much better experience with them than with the agents selling our house. Would highly recommend!

Amelia · 17 June 2019

1/5

Trustpilot

Terrible

1 star given as couldn't give zero. Offered on a Simon Blyth property only to find when the surveyor went in that they had over valued it by £85k as they had marketed it against new builds in the local area. They refused to accept any fault and said the vender wanted to meet us in the middle with a price. We said we were not paying over 40k more for a house than what it was worth and Simon Blyth kept us hanging for a week. We had to chase them daily for updates and they kept telling us that the vender wouldn't go below a certain price. We then decided to look at other houses. We then found out from the vender a week later that they wanted to sell to us at the price the surveyor and had asked Simon Blyth to tell us this but the estate agent hadn't told us this and instead told the vendors that we were unreasonable encouraged them to put their house back on the market. told the vendors that they felt we were being unreasonable. When we told the estate agent we were pulling out of the sale, the very rude woman on the phone said she didn't want to hear our complaint and put the phone down on us. We are £1000 worse off in wasted searches and surveys but we just feel so sorry for the lovely couple we were buying off and hope they never use this estate agent again

Sarah · 23 August 2021

Where the same review appears twice we show it once. We leave out reviews that name another agent or another of the brand's offices.

Read Simon Blyth's Google reviews

Questions about Simon Blyth Penistone

How many reviews does Simon Blyth Penistone have?

Simon Blyth's Penistone office has 141 reviews across two platforms: 103 on Google, 38 on Trustpilot (across the whole business).

What is Simon Blyth Penistone's rating?

Simon Blyth Penistone is rated 4.5 out of 5 across all 141 reviews, and 4.8 out of 5 on Google from 103 reviews.

Where is Simon Blyth's Penistone office?

Simon Blyth Penistone, 1a St. Marys Street, Penistone, S36 6DT.

The Trusted Agent

Is this your office? Claim your page.