Trusted Agent profile

Simon Blyth reviews

4.4

★★★★★ Great

140 reviews across 2 platforms

1a St. Marys Street, Penistone S36 6DT

Simon Blyth's Penistone office at 1a St. Marys Street is rated 4.4 out of 5 across 140 reviews on two platforms, including 103 Google reviews rated 4.8. The 37 Trustpilot count is for the whole business. Checked 9 October 2026.

Google logo

4.8 / 5

103

Reviews on Google

This office

Trustpilot logo

37

Reviews on Trustpilot

Business-wide

Reviews may appear on more than one platform.

Reviews

Every review we hold for the Penistone office, from every platform, shown as written. First names only.

5/5

Google

Ww were very pleased with the service we received from Maria and Scott and the other support staff in the Penistone office. They were very efficient and genuinely helpful. They kept us updated, always returned calls promptly, gave helpful feedback from viewings, were reassuring and ultimately achieved a positive outcome for us

Christine · 16 January 2026

Agent replied · 16 April 2026

Thank you very much for taking the time to leave such a lovely review. It really does mean a great deal to us. I’m so pleased to hear that you were happy with the service provided by our Penistone office. Thank you again for your kind words and for entrusting us with your sale. We wish you and Richard all the very best for the future and would of course be delighted to help again should you ever need us. Kind regards, Maria

5/5

Google

We bought our first home through the Penistone branch, and when it was time to sell, Maria and the team made the process straightforward, being there to help us every step of the way. Maria and her team work incredibly hard to make sure all calls and emails are answered quickly. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend them.

M · 17 January 2024

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you Melanie and Daniel! It was such a pleasure to meet again and to help you complete your sale successfully. We wish you both the very best!

5/5

Google

Maria & Kristy helped us so much during the usual stresses of selling a home. Maria worked really late into the night to get our house on the market in time for the weekend viewings. We paid extra for their professional photographer Dustin to visit us. It was worth every penny as Dustin helped make our house look a million dollars. Maria & Kristy were great at chasing up both sets of solicitors to keep things moving and keeping in touch with us. We would recommend Simon Blyth unreservedly, their fees are very reasonable when you consider the level of service & support you will receive.

Michael · 16 June 2021

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you so much Michael and Wendy!

5/5

Google

We worked with Maria Diaz to sell our home, and we couldn't have been more pleased! We received multiple offers the first week the house went on the market, thanks in large part to Maria’s incredible work. Maria was wonderful in keeping the transaction moving along and getting to closing in a timely manner. She was always available to answer our questions (and the buyers!). She was so responsive and is the sweetest person. We had a great experience!PositiveQuality, Professionalism

Paola · 16 June 2021

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you Paola :)

5/5

Trustpilot

A big thank you to Steve Coley and team…

A big thank you to Steve Coley and team at Stocksbridge . Good old "CUSTOMER SERVICE" at the highest calibre. Very professional from start to completion. Would highly recommend. Wishing you every success for future sales. The Burgess family

Customer · 17 October 2025

5/5

Google

Living overseas and selling our UK property proved to be a stress free experience. This was all due to the efficient service offered by the Penistone office, in particular Maria and Kristy. Between them they organised and conducted around 18 accompanied viewings and always provided us with feedback within 48 hours by either telephone or email. They regularly keep in touch with potential buyers who either had made, or were considering making an offer and kept us informed of any developments. The company's fee structure was reasonable and fair, with no added extras.

Steven · 16 June 2020

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank so much for your feedback! It was a real pleasure to assist you with the sale of your property. All the best to you both.

5/5

Google

We have nothing but positive things to say about Simon Blyth Penistone Branch and especially Maria and Kristy. We recently sold through SB and also bought a house they were selling and I have to say that this was managed excellently. Maria and Kristy managed our sale very professionally, always organised, and prompt feedback. Maria even visited our house with the David (the valuer) which was a nice touch and reassured us potential buyers would receive informed information. Maria was exceptional during the legal process, always managing to get the solicitors focused. Post-completion Maria was still helping with some of the smaller issues that crop up and did so with great care and energy. We couldn't recommend Maria, Kristy and Simon Blyth highly enough.

Emily · 16 June 2020

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you Matt!

5/5

Google

My house sale was handled very smoothly by Maria and Charlotte, at the Penistone branch of Simon Blyth. Maria kept me informed and updated all the time, and offered useful advice when prudent. Also she replied to questions and emails quickly, and was always very positive. I would certainly recommend Simon Blyth Penistone

Adrian · 16 April 2025

5/5

Google

I have just sold my house through the Penistone office . I would like to thank all staff but particularly Maria who led us through the entire process in a friendly and professional manner. All our questions were answered quickly and to our satisfaction and our house sold for the asking price. I would have no hesitation in using them again and would recommend them to any perspective vendor. Thank you.PositiveResponsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value

David · 16 June 2021

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you so much David for your kind words and fantastic review to our business. All the best!

5/5

Google

Staff in Simon Blythe Penistone office are extremely professional, compassionate and well led. Following the valuation David visited my mother in her care home to discuss the process. Maria was generous and compassionate throughout the process, listened and acted on all our wishes. Daniel carried out all the viewings very professionally. Communication throughout the sale was excellent. I would recommend this team to anyone planning to sell their property. Thank you all!

Sarah · 16 May 2024

5/5

Google

We have used the Penistone office to buy our house and also to sell my house and from start to finish the service was first class. I would highly recommend Maria who was simply amazing at making a very stressful time so much easier for us. - her personal intervention meant both sale and purchase stayed on track. Thank you Maria and Simon Blyth for your professionalism.PositiveResponsiveness, Quality, Professionalism

Karen · 25 October 2021

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Hi Karen, thank you so much for such a kind review. We wish you all the best and please get in touch if you need any help in the future. Best regards, Simon Blyth Team

5/5

Google

I was in two minds as to whether to sell my house "myself" or use an estate agent... especially when we received an offer so quickly. Thank goodness I went with Simon Blythe in Penistone! Maria Diaz was a total god send...couldn't have done it without her. Always available, liaising between me and the buyer and solicitors. Helped to smooth out every little problem (and there were alot of them) Would absolutely recommend.

Kristy · 16 June 2020

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you so much Kristy! It was a real pleasure to assist you with the sale of your property. All the best!

1/5

Trustpilot

Avoid

Let’s be honest, more than a little corrupt but also inept. Organised a viewing of a property and took time of work to travel over an hour to it and the appointment had not been put in. Then had someone come over and was rushed to view because of their poor time management. Also when bidding on a property be aware the process isn’t as fair, open and as transparent as it’s portrayed to be.

Sarah · 15 October 2024

Agent replied · 27 July 2025

We do not have your email or number logged on our system so cannot respond as do not have information on which property you are referring to.

5/5

Google

I had a very good experience with Simon Blyth's Penistone office when I sold my house. The terms were favourable, Scott and Maria most helpul, and my house was sold very quickly. Happy times!

Susan · 16 January 2026

Agent replied · 16 April 2026

Dear Susan, I’m really pleased to hear you had a good experience with our Penistone office and that you were happy with the terms, the service from Scott and myself, and the speed of the sale. “Happy times” is exactly what we like to hear. Thank you again for choosing Simon Blyth, and all the very best for the future. Best wishes, Maria

5/5

Google

Maria, Scott and the whole team at the Penistone branch of Simon Blythe are fantastic. Their professional attitudes, proactive performance in selling our house and friendly attitudes would make me recommend them to anyone who could use them. You couldn’t ask for a better team!

Lisa · 2 October 2025

Agent replied · 16 April 2026

Dear Lisa, Thank you so much for such a lovely review. I’m really pleased to hear you were happy with the service we provided throughout the sale. Thank you also for the recommendation, it truly is appreciated. Wishing you all the very best. Best wishes, Maria

5/5

Google

Both Maria and Charlotte were amazing throughout the sale of my property.

Gillian · 16 April 2025

Agent replied · 29 December 2024

Thank you Gill!

5/5

Google

I recently sold my mums house via Simon Blyth at Penistone. The staff were so helpful and the office manager Maria went above and beyond to assist in any way she possibly could. She even assited in areas that normally would be the …

Helen · 16 April 2025

5/5

Trustpilot

Heidi From Simon Blyth - Huddersfield - Outstanding

We first met Heidi at Simon Blyth Huddersfield when we viewed what is now our new home, and from that very first viewing right through to getting the keys, she was exceptional.

Emily · 13 September 2026

5/5

Google

Until we came to sell my late mother's home, I had no idea of how hard estate agents worked. Maria and the team at Simon Blyth in Penistone never stopped working on our behalf, arranging viewings, filtering prospective buyers and just keeping us informed of everything. When the first sale fell through, it was all hands to the deck again!! They were all so lovely to deal with and so efficient and professional. We actually purchased the house through Simon Blyth ten years ago so it was a natural choice to go back to them. A really big THANK YOU to everyone there. We would not hesitate to recommend you to anyone considering buying or selling a property.

Gina · 16 June 2023

5/5

Google

My house sale was handled very smoothly by Maria and Charlotte, at the Penistone branch of Simon Blyth. Maria kept me informed and updated all the time, and offered useful advice when prudent. Also she replied to questions and emails quickly, and was always very positive. I would certainly recommend Simon Blyth Penistone

Adrian · 6 November 2024

5/5

Google

I cannot recommend Simon Blyth’s Penistone office highly enough! As a first-time buyer, they guided me through every single step of the process. They were proactive in communication, always replying quickly to my calls and emails. What could have been a stressful experience turned into exciting and smooth process.

Ben · 15 April 2026

5/5

Google

Moving home is incredibly stressful but Maria and the team at Simon Blyth took the stress away. From the minute Maria valued our home to when we dropped the keys off at the Penistone office on moving day, the team was helpful, supportive, professional and quick to return our calls. I can't recommend Maria highly enough.PositiveResponsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value

Jane · 16 June 2021

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you so much Jane!! We loved your property from the moment we saw it and it was truly pleasure to work on the sale for you. All the best!

5/5

Google

Excellent service from start to completion. We were guided through every stage and Maria and the rest of the team were always available to help. Maria was able to signpost us to a great team to help with the legal aspects of the sale. Nothing was too much trouble .Fantastic team. Highly recommended.

Karen · 16 June 2021

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you so much Karen!! Pleasure to work for you and help with the sell of your lovely property :)

1/5

Google

Unprofessional and devious. Avoid at all cost. The edit below is due to the reply from the business...... The property unexpectedly came back onto the market overnight, we had am alert from rightmove and called the estate agent first thing on the Friday morning. The estate agent's first available appointment was Wednesday the following week. We made the appointment and it was confirmed to us that we were the first callers and that was the first available appointment. If another appointment became available earlier, the estate agent would call us. On the Monday we were called by the Estate Agent and told that it had sold as they took somebody else to view it on the Saturday.

John · 16 June 2023

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Dear Mr Spencer, I am sorry to hear of your dissatisfaction on this occasion. To clarify, you were booked into view a property with us, but before this occurred, another party made an offer that the vendor wished to accept. We provided our vendor with all the information and they decided to cancel your viewing, and a number of others. We acted in full transparency with the information we had and took instruction from our vendor on how they wished to proceed. I appreciate this may not have been agreeable to you, but assure you our actions were all professional and in line with our clients wishes. I wish you well with your ongoing property search. Kind Regards, Maria Diaz Branch Manager

Where the same review appears twice we show it once. We leave out reviews that name another agent or another of the brand's offices.

Read Simon Blyth's Google reviews

Questions about Simon Blyth

How many reviews does Simon Blyth have?

Simon Blyth's Penistone office has 140 reviews across two platforms: 103 on Google, 37 on Trustpilot (across the whole business). Reviews may appear on more than one platform. Checked 9 October 2026.

What is Simon Blyth's rating?

Simon Blyth is rated 4.4 out of 5 across all 140 reviews, and 4.8 out of 5 on Google from 103 reviews, checked 9 October 2026.

Where is Simon Blyth's Penistone office?

Simon Blyth, 1a St. Marys Street, Penistone S36 6DT.

The Trusted Agent

Ratings and review counts checked 9 October 2026. Is this your office? Claim your page.