Trusted Agent profile · Newark

Oliver Reilly Newark reviews

4.9

★★★★★ Excellent

312 reviews across 3 platforms

4 Middle Gate, Newark, NG24 1AG

Oliver Reilly's office in Newark, at 4 Middle Gate, is rated 4.9 out of 5 across 312 reviews on three platforms, including 140 Google reviews rated 4.8.

Google logo

4.8 / 5

140

Reviews on Google

This office

Facebook logo

5.0 / 5

30

Reviews on Facebook

This office

Trustpilot logo

142

Reviews on Trustpilot

This office

Reviews may appear on more than one platform.

Reviews

Every review we hold for the Newark office, from every platform, shown as written. First names only.

5/5

Trustpilot

We have been Simply the Best !!SO lucky in having Oliver…

We have been SO lucky in having Oliver Reilly as our Estate Agent, his professionalism, kindness, guidance, going above and beyond to support us throughout, also Mel has been a gem too, what we have done without you ! 100% recommend Oliver Reilly Estate Agent by far!!

Consumer · 3 May 2024

5/5

Google

Excellent pro active, professional and friendly team. I got lots of interest and offers as soon as the property went on the market. Oliver then went on to match us to our ideal home which he had just valued. Always quick to reply to …

Joanne · 17 January 2026

5/5

Trustpilot

Well managed and efficient

Very help and pleasant staff, sale well managed and efficiently dealt with. Very personable nothing too much trouble.

Lesley · 3 August 2026

5/5

Google

First used Oliver Reilly to purchase our home back in 2023. The experience was so positive that we went back to them when it came to selling. Again, they were professional, courteous and on the ball. They happily followed up on any question …

Paul · 17 January 2026

5/5

Google

Excellent service 5 star just moved into my house today Oliver and his team done everything with lots of effort and care about me! Highly recommended Agancy! I will using them in the future and just offering to everyone who wants a smooth move! Thank you so much

Henrik · 17 March 2024

5/5

Trustpilot

Sold recently with Oliver Rilley

After over a year of attempting to sell a property with different agents I approached Oliver. The property in question was outside his usual area but he was keen and enthusiastic to give it a go. All I can say is I whish I'd of approached him sooner. The property completed sale on November 15th 2024 after only being on the market with him for around 6 weeks. He went above and beyond to secure a sale, dealing with all viewings although the property was an hour round trip for him.

John · 2 December 2024

5/5

Google

When looking for a house in the Newark area the team at Oliver Reilly were extremely helpful with setting up viewings and arranging times. Throughout the buying process they checked in and were very helpful when all of our questions as …

Leah · 17 January 2026

5/5

Trustpilot

Best estate agent in Newark

5 Star service from Oliver Reilly Estate Agents. Oliver and Mel were professional, friendly and always keeping us up to date with progress of the sale of our property. Highly recommend if you require an efficient, well managed service when buying or selling a property.Sarah & Paul

Sarah · 11 January 2024

5/5

Trustpilot

Fantastic service

Fantastic service , very knowledgable and communication is 1 st class. Nothing too much trouble , thank you Oliver and staff for selling my house in a very professional way

Pauline · 3 April 2026

5/5

Google

We recently bought a house through Oliver Reilly. Mel was absolutely fantastic all through the process, keeping us in the loop and checking up on things for us. Thank you.

Olivia · 3 November 2024

5/5

Google

Huge thank you to both Oliver and Mel for the service and support during our moving process. They were both supportive and helpful throughout and we can’t thank them enough. They’re professional, easy to contact and follow up and get back to you to help make the whole process as seamless and stress free as possible. If you’re in or around Newark and looking for a great Estate Agency then don’t hesitate to contact Oliver Riley! Thanks again, Alex & Hannah

Alex · 24 September 2024

5/5

Google

I didn't use Oliver to sell our house but I wish I had! I met him as he was acting on behalf of the sellers of the property we were buying and you wouldn't think his business had been running for less than a year. Throughout our chain of 4 properties Oliver was the person who became my go-to person and kept me most updated. Moving house is not something most people do very often so aren't aware of who does what but Oliver was always very professional in his attitude and available when we needed answers. I really couldn't recommend him highly enough.

Chris · 16 June 2022

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Dear Mr McGrady. Thank you so much for your lovely words. It was a pleasure to help you where I could. Despite not acting on the sale of your property. I was happy to share any advice I could to ensure the transaction met its inevitable completion date. I wish you many years of happiness in your wonderfully quirky and charming home and thank you once again for your kind words. All the best. Oliver

5/5

Google

My Sister and I sadly losed our Father in February 2021, and as executors we had to deal with his affairs including the sale of his flat in central Newark. After contacting 2 other Estate Agents we chose Oliver Reilly, for both of us this was a bit of a gamble as Oliver is a new business in Newark. I called Oliver and he came straight round to the flat, we talked about the flat and he provided details of similar properties in the area to back up the sales price, however for us and more importantly he listened and was sympathetic and empatheitic under the circumstances. Oliver lined up viewings and within about 48hrs had a firm offer, unfortunately the buyers backed out a day later. Whilst we felt gutted, Oliver was very positive and reassuring, and advised he already had another potential couple interested, he contacted them and made an appointment for them to view the property. An offer was made and accepted. During the process of obtaining probate Oliver kept ourselves and the buyers up to date, he reassured us that the buyers were still interested even after waiting several months, and also kept the buyers informed of progress. Olivers strap line is "Passionate about Property", and he certainly is. He is professional, calm and very level headed. Nothing fazed him and he got the sale across the line for the asking price even when it seemed that probate was never going to finish. We want to thank Oliver for his conduct, as having someone like Oliver on our side to sell at a very raw time made things just that little bit easier and took a lot of pressure off. I have and will continue to recommend Oliver Reilly to friends and family and will use him again if needed in the future.

James · 16 June 2022

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thanks James. What a fantastic review. Thank you for 'taking a chance' on a new business. It was a very bumpy road, due to the nature of the sale but I am delighted we reached a positive outcome, for all parties involved. Thank you for flying the flag for my business, it means more than you will ever know! Regards, Oliver

5/5

Google

Whilst looking for our first property move in 37 years we were fortunate enough to come across Oliver Reilly Estate Agents. His help and advice during the process was invaluable. If it had not been for Oliver we would still be awaiting the legal process to finalize our property purchase. His professionalism, personability and enthusiasm were far beyond what we expected. This gentleman deserves all the success that is surely coming his way as he is a top bloke and I would not hesitate to recommend him to anyone, and he even chases solicitors!PositiveResponsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value

Neil · 16 June 2022

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you for your lovely words. It was a very rocky road but something that was out of everyone's control. I truly hope now you have moved and (hopefully) settled into your new home, its been worth the wait! All the best for the future and thank you for your patience and understanding, throughout the whole process. Regards, Oliver.

5/5

Google

If Oliver had been in business a year ago I would of undoubtedly put my property on the market with him. Luckily enough though I was able to purchase my new chapter with him instead & I’m so grateful. Oliver, is hard working, passionate and professional, he is extremely responsive and nothing is too much trouble. The journey & experience of my property purchase was stress free from the first viewing to completion, he went above and beyond and I couldn’t thank him enough. I would highly recommend his business to anyone. You have a bright future Oliver, keep doing what you’re doing and you’ll fly!PositiveResponsiveness

Adrianna · 16 June 2022

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you so much Adrianna. It was a thoroughly enjoyable process to deal with you from start to finish and a pleasure to find your long term home. I just know you will make it amazing! Thanks again, Oliver

1/5

Google

My daughter was let down by Newark branch . Misleading advertising on property she was going to buy they said it had uPVC double glazing and garage . Wooden framed windows plus dilapidated garage built of asbestos that needs pulling down and taken away . All Ready to exchange contracts. She has lost thousands thanks to their lies.

******** · 17 March 2024

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Good evening. The property I believe you are referring to has not been falsely advertised. The house itself does have uPVC double glazing. There may be wooden external frames and ledges but the windows are still constructed of uPVC. Albeit, in an older style. We do not specify the age of the windows/ glazing. That is to be clarified by the solicitors. Hence the 'subject to contract' statement on any agreed sale. Therefore if the information provided is not acceptable, your daughter could withdraw at anytime. It is evident from viewing the property externally, of the condition and style of the windows. The only windows which are not uPVC are on the utility room. The information provided on our details states: ' majority uPVC double glazing throughout. This excludes the two wooden windows in the utility room'. We also include particular information regarding each room. Under the' utility room' it specifically states: 'Wooden double glazed window to the right side and rear elevation. An external left side door gives access into the rear garden'. We have documented there is a concrete garage and have not commented on if the roof is asbestos, or not. We are not qualified to confirm this. We therefore recommend to all purchasers to have an independent survey to clarify any further details, make observations and sensible recommendations on any remedial works required. This is written clearly on ALL of our property details. My understanding is that the property your daughter wishes to purchase is still going ahead, subject to a new price to being agreed, following the results of a survey, which was arranged after 3 months of the sale being agreed. She was not forced to proceed with the conveyancing until she had arranged a survey. This is usually one of the first courses of action. Which we also recommend at the beginning of a transaction. Therefore no other costs would have been encountered, other than the payment for the survey, which is always at the risk of any buyer. Some purchasers wait for the results of a survey, before engaging with solicitors and incurring costs. I also understand your daughter has revisited this property more than three times, over various periods, to assess the workload required. One of which has recently been with the vendor himself. The condition of the property has not changed since her first viewing back in November 2023. The property is advertised as requiring a modernisation scheme. Which is apparent from our photos and description. It would also be apparent after the first, second and third viewing, etc. Along with information and recommendations from an independent chartered surveyor. It is HUGELY disappointing to read that you feel we have lied to secure a sale. We haven't! We are working with both vendor and purchaser (your daughter) to try and find a resolution and see the sale through to completion. You are more than welcome to contact our branch directly and engage in a conversation to discuss these points further. Which is something we have been doing with your daughter this week, to keep the sale from falling through, for everyone's sake. We will continue to do this, in the hope the sale can reach a successful conclusion.

5/5

Trustpilot

Excellent communication, efficient and professional.

Thank you so much to the Oliver Reilly Newark team- Mel and Sarah especially, for your efficiency and excellent communication throughout our first home purchase process!

Tess · 4 April 2026

5/5

Trustpilot

Excellent from start to finish

Oliver was very professional and listened to my requirements, he went above and beyond to find my perfect home. The whole process from start to finish was seamless, largely due to Oliver’s responsiveness and excellent communication skills. Promptly answering calls and emails, keeping me informed every step of the way. If you’re looking for a personable, friendly and communicative team I can’t recommend Oliver Reilly highly enough.

Fay · 8 February 2025

5/5

Trustpilot

What every Estate Agent wishes they could be...

My Sister and I sadly losed our Father in February 2021, and as executors we had to deal with his affairs including the sale of his flat in central Newark.After contacting 2 other Estate Agents we chose Oliver Reilly, for both of us this was a bit of a gamble as Oliver is a new business in Newark.I called Oliver and he came straight round to the flat, we talked about the flat and he provided details of similar properties in the area to back up the sales price, however for us and more importantly he listened and was sympathetic and empatheitic under the circumstances.Oliver lined up viewings and within about 48hrs had a firm offer, unfortunately the buyers backed out a day later.Whilst we felt gutted, Oliver was very positive and reassuring, and advised he already had another potential couple interested, he contacted them and made an appointment for them to view the property.An offer was made and accepted. During the process of obtaining probate Oliver kept ourselves and the buyers up to date, he reassured us that the buyers were still interested even after waiting several months, and also kept the buyers informed of progress.Olivers strap line is "Passionate about Property", and he certainly is. He is professional, calm and very level headed. Nothing fazed him and he got the sale across the line for the asking price even when it seemed that probate was never going to finish.We want to thank Oliver for his conduct, as having someone like Oliver on our side to sell at a very raw time made things just that little bit easier and took a lot of pressure off.I have and will continue to recommend Oliver Reilly to friends and family and will use him again if needed in the future.

James · 2 December 2021

Agent replied · 17 June 2024

Thanks James. What a fantastic review. Thank you for 'taking a chance' on a new business. It was a very bumpy road, due to the nature of the sale but I am delighted we reached a positive outcome, for all parties involved. Thank you for flying the flag for my business, it means more than you will ever know! Regards, Oliver

5/5

Trustpilot

Professional

Professional, knowledgable and personable. These are few out of the many positive words I could use to describe Oliver. Oliver’s has gone above and beyond helping me over the past 4 years with my own properties whether it is buying, selling and renting, always delivering and getting the results fast and efficiently through an outstanding level of quality of work. Oliver will comeback on a sunny day to make sure he has got the perfect outside shot of your home you wish to sell. Always that bit extra! Oliver’s passion for the job and helping his customers unmatched. It is always a pleasure to see him and it is great to know as a customer that whatever my endeavour I can always rely on Oliver to get me sorted out. Today marks the day of another completion with Oliver being there every step of the way for both myself and the current vendors. Truly exceptional.Oliver, thank-you

Bill · 2 November 2021

Agent replied · 17 June 2024

Bill,Its always a pleasure to help and assist where possible. Best of luck with the newest addition to your portfolio and I look forward to assisting you where I can in the near future.Oliver

5/5

Google

Very easy to work with, Debra is always on hand to help, would recommend!

Harry · 26 March 2025

5/5

Trustpilot

Property purchase review

I recently purchased my new property through Oliver and I couldn’t recommend him enough! The company slogan says it all, ‘passionate about property’ and that he certainly is! Nothing is ever to much trouble for Oliver. Continuously professional, personable and informative throughout. I would confidentially recommend his services to anyone. Oliver Reilly Estate Agents may be in its infancy but don’t let that deter you… Oliver has extensive knowledge of the market and a fantastic forward thinking approach that outshines the competition. I have no doubt that the future will remain extremely bright. Thanks again Oliver.

Sophie · 4 October 2021

Agent replied · 17 June 2024

Thank you for you lovely words Sophie. It was my pleasure to assist you with your purchase. I am hugely grateful for the support you have shown. I am confident you and Bertie will be very happy in your superbly stylish home! Don't be a stranger! Regards, Oliver

5/5

Facebook

I recently purchased my new property through Oliver and I couldn’t recommend him enough! The company slogan says it all, ‘passionate about property’ and that he certainly is! Nothing is ever to much trouble for Oliver. Continuously professional, personable and informative throughout. I would confidentially recommend his services to anyone. Oliver Reilly Estate Agents may be in its infancy but don’t let that deter you… Oliver has extensive knowledge of the market and a fantastic forward thinking approach that outshines the competition. I have no doubt that the future will remain extremely bright. Thanks again Oliver.

Sophie · 4 October 2021

Agent replied · 22 April 2026

Thank you for you lovely words Sophie. It was my pleasure to assist you with your purchase. I am hugely grateful for the support you have shown. I am confident you and Bertie will be very happy in your superbly stylish home! Don't be a stranger! Regards, Oliver

5/5

Trustpilot

5 star 🌟 and Kind hearted!

Well what can we say! Words will never be enough. Oliver offers a 5 star service, the care and compassion he puts into not only his work but to ensure everything you need it sorted. We bought our first house with Oliver, it was stressful and overwhelming with daunting moments but Oliver did his job plus everyone else's. He explained things we didn't know, chased all parties and companies to ensure the sale was sorted. Went out of his way to go above and beyond. Would never use anyone else, Oliver is your esate agent king! Thanks for everything Oliver!

Nicole · 3 October 2021

Agent replied · 17 June 2024

A real pleasure Nicole. Thank you for your humbling words. It great to assist you in purchasing your new home, I just know you will make the house amazing, in time. Best wishes for the future to you and your family and hope our paths cross again in the future. Regards, Oliver

Where the same review appears twice we show it once. We leave out reviews that name another agent or another of the brand's offices.

Read Oliver Reilly's Google reviews

Questions about Oliver Reilly Newark

How many reviews does Oliver Reilly Newark have?

Oliver Reilly's Newark office has 312 reviews across three platforms: 140 on Google, 30 on Facebook, 142 on Trustpilot.

What is Oliver Reilly Newark's rating?

Oliver Reilly Newark is rated 4.9 out of 5 across all 312 reviews, and 4.8 out of 5 on Google from 140 reviews.

Where is Oliver Reilly's Newark office?

Oliver Reilly Newark, 4 Middle Gate, Newark, NG24 1AG.

The Trusted Agent

Is this your office? Claim your page.