Trusted Agent profile · Edinburgh · Scotland

McEwan Fraser Legal Edinburgh reviews

★★★★★ Excellent

927 reviews across 1 platform

Claremont House, 130 East Claremont Street, Edinburgh, Scotland, EH7 4LB

McEwan Fraser Legal's office in Edinburgh, Scotland, at Claremont House, is rated 4.5 out of 5 across 927 reviews on 1 platform, including 927 Google reviews rated 4.5. It won Trusted Agent in The Trusted Agent 2026 awards.

Google logo

4.5 / 5

927

Reviews on Google

This office

Reviews

Every review we hold for the Edinburgh office, from every platform, shown as written. First names only.

5/5

Google

I was very pleased to deal with the Legal Executive who I was assigned. She was professional, approachable and un-pretentious. I was very pleased with the service I received. Thank you Kim.

Simon · 29 April 2021

Agent replied

Thank you for leaving a review of your experience with McEwan Fraser Legal. Your feedback is really appreciated, and allows us to continually monitor and improve the service we provide to our clients. I will pass on your kind words to Katie, and the team

1/5

Google

Without going in to all the details, I can only say that the level of incompetence I encountered from using MFL in selling my property and purchasing another (neither of which happened ultimately), was quite simply astounding. They managed to make what is already a highly stressful situation 10 times more stressful by being incapable of following though with actions they stated they would, or that I requested, and generally just providing a well bellow adequate service. For a start they provided a brochure that was so riddled with grammatical errors, and just generally did NOT actually SELL my property, that I actually had to rewrite the text myself...and that was just the start of the never-ending issues that cropped up. If MFL invested even half as much time & effort into marketing the properties of their clients as they do their own company, they might be half way to fulfilling their own advertising claims. Edit: In response to the comment left by MFL - I submitted a detailed official complaint to MFL last year, which I received a response to at the end of last month. And I can assure you the response in no way resolved ANYTHING. It was a wholly biased report which skewed events (and was peppered with patronising and snide remarks), and did not take in to consideration the overarching premise of my complaint which was that the repeated errors, oversights etc that meant I was constantly having to monitor the work MFL should have been doing, caused me significant stress and ultimately the standard of service was grossly inadequate. I had waited to receive the response before posting any reviews as I believed that only to be fair, but now that I have received the response, and MFL are still accepting no accountability for the litany of errors, I will share my experience in the hope that others may avoid going through the additional stress of using an estate agency who are incompetent and provide substandard services.

Grace · 13 April 2021

Agent replied

We're sorry to hear that you were not satisfied with the service provided by McEwan Fraser Legal. We would appreciate if you could contact us through this link https://www.mcewanfraserlegal.co.uk/contact with details so we can look into this for you. We take all feedback and reviews seriously and will do our best to resolve this to your complete satisfaction. Kind regards, McEwan Fraser Legal

1/5

Google

Had an exceptionally poor experience using this firm. They sat on the work for an extended period of time, poor communication, made mistakes, gave me advice that I understand to be contrary to legal requirements and then tried to claim they didn't understand my complaint. I gave up in the end but they did refund the fee. I would add that it was a trainee that was responsible for the work so maybe fully trained solicitors and partners at this firm would have done better. I will never use this firm again as they wasted my time and cost me money.

Gareth · 20 March 2021

Agent replied

We're sorry to hear that you were not satisfied with the service provided by McEwan Fraser Legal. We would appreciate if you could contact us through this link https://www.mcewanfraserlegal.co.uk/contact with details so we can look into this for you. We take all feedback and reviews seriously and will do our best to resolve this to your complete satisfaction. Kind regards, McEwan Fraser Legal

1/5

Google

SHOCKING, NOT EVEN WORTH ONE STAR !!!! This company in particular the Paisley branch are to be avoided at all costs. We offered on a property in person to the seller which was accepted, unfortunately it had just went to closing,the seller phoned the following morning to ask the EA take it off the market, the EA told the seller she would be in breach of contract if she didn't go to closing date.!!! So the seller went to closing date, !!! CLOSING DATE , the sellers kept to their word and sold to us. even though they had higher offers. We didn't even get a call from this EA to say we had been successful with the property. It was our solicitor that called us at 4.30 to let us know and told us she had to phone the EA and ask for an update, the closing time was 1pm !!!!! Luckily for us the sellers called us at 1. 30 to congratulate us on getting the property. THEN the sellers told us the EA called them AFTER closing date on the Saturday morning to give them another offer. This is very unethical and highly unprofessional after a closing date. Luckily for us the seller didn't accept and wanted us to have the house. We are in our dream home now, NO thanks to this EA, Don't touch them and I would never recommend them.

Sharon · 5 March 2021

Agent replied

We regret to report this negative review is misguided. Once a seller has set a closing date, they are obliged in the interest of fairness and transparency to all buyers who have formally expressed an interest in a property, to allow these potential buyers to submit an offer at closing date, and to do otherwise would compromise the integrity of the home buying process in Scotland. As a firm of Solicitors, we are regulated by the Law Society of Scotland and we are not permitted to contact another Solicitors client, so we informed your own Solicitor of the outcome of your successful offer. We are also duty-bound to bring any subsequent offers to our client in case an offer falls through and we informed the buyer that the property was under offer. We would need to withdraw from acting for our client if they decided to accept another offer after a formal offer had been accepted. This firm followed all the correct procedures and acted as any other legal form would have done in the said circumstances.

5/5

Google

Absolutely outstanding service from McEwan Fraser. Amazing turnaround on a fast purchase, with updates when needed at all hours of the clock. Highly recommend, and will definitely use again! Can't thank Magnus, Ranald, Sophie & co. enough for their help.

Simon · 17 January 2017

Agent replied

Hi Simon, thanks for your feedback and will definitely pass your message to the team here at MFL.

5/5

Google

i thank you for your service, you quite simply have done me proud, as the saying goes, you have done"what it says on the tin" in particular I would like to thank Lauren Duffus, a absolutely brilliant job well done.

George · 17 January 2017

Agent replied

Hi, George, Thank you for the review, we are all very happy we have done you proud. I will pass on your great comments to Lauren.

2/5

Google

Not the best experience and not award winning in my opinion. They required regular interventions from me as the client, despite their glossy sales pitch, premium price tag and unfulfilled promise of communication. I would not use MFL again. Issues included: spelling and grammar errors in my brochure; pictures taken from a child's eye level; limited and low quality images used in the virtual tour; MFL didn't confirm the property was loaded onto property portal websites so didn't spot an error in their system; MFL relied on a clunky proprietary messaging system rather than build rapport; stats did not show on their dashboard without prompt and were of limited value as they were only collated weekly and did not indicate conversions to brochure requests or viewings; viewing bookings were loaded for New year's Eve until prompted; MFL solicitors just parked my file once an offer was made without acknowledging whether the formal acceptance had been actioned; MFL solicitors failed to communicate or respond to requests for progress updates without repeated called and emails.

Ashley · 22 February 2021

Agent replied

We're sorry to hear that you were not satisfied with the service provided by McEwan Fraser Legal. We would appreciate if you could contact us through this link https://www.mcewanfraserlegal.co.uk/contact with details so we can look into this for you. We take all feedback and reviews seriously and will do our best to resolve this to your complete satisfaction. Kind regards, McEwan Fraser Legal

5/5

Google

Very efficient and kept me up to speed in selling /buying my property Magnus was great and all the other members of the team would recommend

Åse · 12 March 2022

Agent replied

Thank you for leaving a review of your experience with McEwan Fraser Legal. Your feedback is really appreciated and allows us to continually monitor and improve the service we provide to our clients. I will pass on your kind words to Magnus and the team.

5/5

Google

The team at McEwan Fraser have been amazing with the sale of my property from the minute I first contacted them. They made the whole process so simple - valuation, photos, marketing, viewings and everything else in between. Ben, Logan, Finlay and Artur have always been at the end of the phone when I’ve needed them and answered emails promptly. I felt very well guided and looked after throughout. Would highly recommend!

Carly · 15 June 2022

Agent replied

Hi Carly, thank you for leaving a review of your experience with McEwan Fraser Legal. Your feedback is really appreciated and allows us to continually monitor and improve the service we provide to our clients. I will pass on your comments to Ben and the team.

5/5

Google

Recently a very close friends of mine had to deal with the company and especially with Maya James. Mrs James have provided impeccable service to them with purchasing their first home in Scotland. From the initial contact to the handing over the keys everything was perfect. Easy to talk to, very good communication skills and ever present smile. Mrs James is an excellent ambassador for your company.

Alex · 22 March 2020

5/5

Google

My husband and I are endlessly thankful for the help we have received from McEwan Fraser Legal and specifically Ms Maya James. I daresay that her swift help providing us with Independent Legal Advice was key to us completing the purchase on time. Not only was she a pleasure to work with, but she was highly professional, which is especially vital in our matter with property purchase.

Margarita · 22 March 2020

1/5

Google

After finding a house to purchase the seller has been using this company and the service from them has been nothing bit shocking. No communication to the seller, no communication to.our solicitor and even on the day we are due to settle we have only just recieved the written acceptance with a lot of our clauses removed! We are sitting here with vans loaded and ready to go and now we are being told it could take another two days due enviromental searches not being done. I bought this house 2 months ago for crying out loud!!! Even the seller has contacted me to ask what is going on as they havent heard anything from McEwans Fraser. Although i havent directly used this company i would avoid them with a barge pole as first impressions count and they are shocking at communicating with people!NegativeResponsiveness, Professionalism

Kevin · 10 January 2021

Agent replied

Hello Kevin. As you are not our client we are not permitted to communicate with you. I think you will find we responded timeously to your solicitors communication and suggest you ask your solicitor for your file. It is the buying solicitor who concludes the purchase not the selling solicitor.

5/5

Google

I chose McEwan Fraser over the others I researched and am very glad I did. The service they provide is second to none, particularly the out of hours, 7 days a week availability as most enquiries seemed to be in the evening or weekends and they were right on it. From Mike the Surveyor to Logan the Consultant appointed to me, I cannot thank them enough for their on point communications, professionalism and efficiency. I sold very quickly and with ease and they actually made it quite fun ! The dashboard system incorporated is extremely useful from a sellers point of view and seriously helps keep track of all stages of the process - a very useful tool. I would highly recommend the enhanced package due to the nationwide coverage as opposed to just local, it definitely is good from a marketing prospective. I would not hesitate to use them again and to recommend them to others. Thank you.

Gillian · 19 December 2020

Agent replied

Thank you for leaving a review of your experience with McEwan Fraser Legal. Your feedback is really appreciated, and allows us to continually monitor and improve the service we provide to our clients. I will pass on your kind words to Mike, and the team.

5/5

Google

My name is Graham and I sold my property with McEwan Fraser Legal at 15 Cairnie Crescent, Arbroath.I could not have hoped for a better service. Karla was excellent communication was superb and her manner was very pleasing

Graham · 17 January 2018

Agent replied

Hi Graham, thank you for taking the time to write such a lovely review. I will pass the praise to Karla.

5/5

Google

Finlay was a massive help to me as a first time buyer and answered any questions I had would thoroughly recommend using McEwan Fraser legal

Martyn · 12 March 2022

Agent replied

Thank you for leaving a review of your experience with McEwan Fraser Legal. Your feedback is really appreciated, and allows us to continually monitor and improve the service we provide to our clients. I will pass on your kind words to Finlay, and the team.

1/5

Google

I have had a very poor experience with McEwan Fraser Legal. When we put our house on the market we were lucky enough to get an acceptable offer straight away which we accepted. It was then the trouble began. Our case sat on someone's desk for 5 weeks without any progress. I was assured that, despite this, we would still exchange on the agreed date. This begs the question: if it can be done this quickly, why isn't it always? In fact we hit a couple of snags. The person dealing with our case was incapable of explaining things to us in plain English, and had no viable suggestions to solve it, so eventually the sale fell through. After this, and with our own research we resolved the main issue ourselves but it was all too late. The property then sat on the market empty for 18 months. We lost our 2nd home tax rebate. Eventually I sacked McEwan Fraser and relisted with someone better, and the property sold within the week. I would not recommend this company to anyone. They charge exorbitant amounts and that's not reflected at all in the quality of the service. The legal assigned to us was incompetent and the attitude of the company as a whole is arrogant and complacent.

Jan · 18 October 2020

Agent replied

We're sorry to hear that you were not satisfied with the service provided by McEwan Fraser Legal. We would appreciate if you could contact us through this link https://www.mcewanfraserlegal.co.uk/contact with details so we can look into this for you. We take all feedback and reviews seriously and will do our best to resolve this to your complete satisfaction. Kind regards, McEwan Fraser Legal

5/5

Google

McEwan Fraser Legal have been fantastic throughout the house sale and buying process for my wife and I. The team are very quick to respond to queries, to resolve any problems and explained the process to us as novice house sellers, which is particularly impressive during this busy and testing time for the market. They are professional, knowledgeable and client focused providing an excellent service. We really felt that McEwan Fraser Legal went above and beyond for us and we would not hesitate to use their services again. We would highly recommend McEwan Fraser Legal for both house purchase and sale.

Graeme · 18 October 2020

Agent replied

Thank you for leaving a review of your experience with McEwan Fraser Legal. Your feedback is really appreciated, and allows us to continually monitor and improve the service we provide to our clients.

5/5

Google

I have had a particularly difficult experience with my selling process due to the buyer's solicitor not providing good communication with either his clients (my buyer) or my solicitor Jadiene Morison (and Kenneth Daley who covered her holiday). However, both Jadiene and Kenneth remained professional and helpful throughout the process and guided me through a particularly tricky sale process with great competence. I particularly appreciate the level of patience they both had with me during a stressful period in my life! I thank them both. I was also very happy with the level of service and communication I had with Anneka Torrance and Ben Stewart Clark. I wish to thank all team members who have assisted me throughout this process. I look forward to recommending Mcewan Fraser to family and friends in the future.

Amy · 18 October 2020

Agent replied

Thank you for leaving a review of your experience with McEwan Fraser Legal. Your feedback is really appreciated, and allows us to continually monitor and improve the service we provide to our clients. I will pass on your kind words to Jadiene , and the team.

5/5

Google

MFL did a fantastic job of marketing our property in Dundee and sold the property in about three weeks. James Keet was excellent as a representative of the company explaining how it all would work and the office kept me up to date with all movements going on behind the scenes on my web bulletin board. I am sure they secured a top price for my property exceeding my initial expectations.

Alastair · 18 January 2015

5/5

Google

Thank you to Darren, Lewis and all the MFL team for selling my flat in 6 weeks. A first class service from start to finish. I would definitely recommend your service to anyone thinking of selling their property.

Elaine · 17 January 2017

Agent replied

Hi Elaine, thank you for the review, will pass the praise to the team.

5/5

Google

Conveyancing completed within a quick timescale and good communication along the way. Sophie and Magnus were both highly professional and easy to do business with and I look forward o dealing with them both again in the future.

Sarah · 17 January 2017

Agent replied

Hi Sarah, Thank you for your review, I will pass on your praise to Magnus and Sophie.

5/5

Google

Found Amanda extremely helpful in seeing us through the process of marketing and accepting an offer our property (Langton Grove, East Calder). Would recommend her and the team at MFL Edinburgh. Thanks Amanda!

Elle · 12 March 2020

Agent replied

Hi Louise, thanks again for choosing McEwan Fraser Legal!

5/5

Google

Would like to thank Nick & Jadiene at McEwan & Fraser for selling my flat within a week you done an amazing job would recommend McEwan & Fraser for selling your property 😍😍

Donna · 17 January 2020

Agent replied

Hi Donna, thank you for your five-star rating. We will pass on your thanks to the team!

5/5

Google

Out of hours availability was very helpful and plenty interest and viewing requests were generated for our property. Magnus was able to push through the legal's quickly and smoothly.

Mark · 24 January 2021

Agent replied

Thank you for leaving a review of your experience with McEwan Fraser Legal. Your feedback is really appreciated, and allows us to continually monitor and improve the service we provide to our clients. I will pass on your kind words to Magnus, and the team.

Where the same review appears twice we show it once. We leave out reviews that name another agent or another of the brand's offices.

Read McEwan Fraser Legal's Google reviewsLeave McEwan Fraser Legal a review

Awards

The Trusted Agent 2026 results for McEwan Fraser Legal, ranked against 18,569 UK estate agent offices. Each award is assessed separately from the review sites.

Industry awards

McEwan Fraser Legal Edinburgh won The Negotiator Awards in five years, most recently 2019.

Negotiator Awards winner in five years: 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015.

Negotiator Awards by year, 2019 to 2015

Source: The Negotiator Awards winners lists, as published, linked by year.

Want a trusted local agent to help?

Tell us what you need and we'll put you in touch. McEwan Fraser Legal hasn't joined The Trusted Agent yet, so we'll pass your enquiry to them or to up to three other top-rated agents near Edinburgh.

What do you need help with?

Questions about McEwan Fraser Legal Edinburgh

Has McEwan Fraser Legal won any awards?

Yes. McEwan Fraser Legal won Trusted Agent in The Trusted Agent 2026 awards. It also won Silver for Employer of the Year and Silver for Regional Agency of the Year, Scotland at The Negotiator Awards 2019, and 7 other industry awards since 2015.

Reviews may appear on more than one platform.

The Trusted Agent

Is this your office? Claim your page.

Get help from an agent