Every review we hold for the Royal Sutton Coldfield office, from every platform, shown as written. First names only.
★★★★★ 1/5
GoogleBy far the worst letting agency we have ever used. How anyone has ever given them more than 1 star I have no idea. If I could give them less I would. Every time we ring we get passed from pillar to post promised phone calls back and nothing. Been going on four weeks now and when the rental contract came through it was wrong. Spoken to them again twice and it's still come through wrong twice. Absolutely diabolical service. Please AVOID AVOID AVOID AVOID!!!!!!!
Chris · 13 June 2024
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotGreat service
Great service - Megan was always responsive to calls and very quickly processed my flat rental when she knew I was in a hurry! She was friendly, helpful and even managed to negotiate a slight reduction in monthly rent for me. An excellent experience.
Sarah · 28 September 2023
★★★★★ 1/5
TrustpilotDO NOT GO WITH
I would never in a million year recommend this company the staff are shocking and the way they treat customers is appalling! I have fought with this company for 5 months over a £750 deposit that they refused to release to myself. My flat that they were supposed to manage and look after is and absolute DISGRACEFUL TIP, they never fixed any problems and if they did it was a half arsed job! My Tenant had called them multiple times with occurring problems asking them to fix them and no one ever got back to her! The reason for having a leasing agent is to take a weight of the Landlord's shoulders with one less issue to deal with! Leah and Julie (at the Sutton Coldfield branch) are an waste of time to even speak to! They truly do not care about helping anyone, they ignore multiple phone calls and emails! If you are looking for a lease agent to manage any property of your DO NOT use John Shepherd! If you ever decide to use them get ready to contact the Property Ombudsmen to file a complaint to try and get your Tenants deposit back because as soon as you want to end your agreement with them and change leasing agents or do all the work yourself it is going to be a ball ache and very stressful time getting that deposit back! Please learn from my mistake of going with them they are an utter joke!!!If I was able to give them 0 stars I would!
Jess · 3 June 2024
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotIt's been a great experience working…
It's been a great experience working with Lily and the team. She was responsive from the first contact, and now, with no hassle the first tenant is set to move in. Everything was handled smoothly, clearly and on time. Thank you!
Tim · 24 November 2023
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotJack & Tasha professional agents
Jack & Tasha were excellent agents, professional, friendly and had passion for selling the house. They were in touch all the time, nothing was too much trouble and throughout offered support, guidance and made us feel safe in their hands … ambassadors in their field for John Sheppard
Customer · 23 May 2023
★★★★★ 1/5
TrustpilotFrom Bad to Worse
I have had a number of issues with this letting agency as a landlord since they'd taken over Wolfs. Here's just a few:1. My tenant is on housing benefit which is paid to JS weekly. Accordingly I used to get paid weekly and then overnight paid monthly with no prior warning or consultation. I've raised this on a few occasions and despite their promises to get back to me, no one ever has.2. I was told that a legionella risk assessment was necessary a few months' back, which I had paid for and believe to have been carried out, but not received it.3. I had instructed a EICR (electrical certificate) to be carried out such that the payment would be deducted for the rental period end of May but it has been taken out end - April. Seemingly unable to follow simple instructions.4. Both of the said works above are offered at a substantial premium over market rates (e.g. £225 for an electrical cert), suggesting that JS mark these up, despite charging a monthly management fee for lettings. Where's the fairness in that?5. The fees for such works are deducted at point of instruction (Reserve Funds Held) and not at the point in which the work is carried out, which in some instances are weeks' apart. No doubt JS will have credit terms with their contractors and yet they are happy to withhold rent ahead of work undertaken playing havoc with the landlord's cash flow.It seems that when I raise concerns they do not appear to be passed upwards to the powers that be and even if they do I never get any feedback. There appears to be very little accountability with the company directors registered in Scotland and Yorkshire. For this reason I felt it necessary to share these concerns with other Landlords considering using John Shepherd as their agent. Note I have a small portfolio of buy to let investment properties and do not encounter such issues with other agents.
BhamAnon · 4 May 2021
Agent replied · 13 June 2024
Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review, we’re sorry to hear your experience has not been as we’d hope at this point. We are very keen to speak directly to understand more specifically what the issues you have experienced are and how we can rectify them. Please email our Lettings Director at jack.spellman@johnshepherd.com and he will be happy to discuss more. Many thanks
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotI have just rented a beautiful property…
I have just rented a beautiful property through John Shepherd Estate Agent. Lily initially showed me around and she was brilliant from the outset! Really professional, and very calm, especially, when we hit a milestone, she was really patient and persistent. I would not hesitate to recommend Lily and the team at John Shepherd Estate Agents
Deanne · 21 July 2022
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotGreat service very helpful and a brilliant maintenance team
Good communication and got the job done with a brilliant maintenance team
Anj · 21 September 2025
Agent replied · 25 September 2025
Thank you for your review! 😁
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotI had a great experience with the John…
I had a great experience with the John Shepherd Estate agents. The staff is very helpful and comprehensive. The tenancy process was handled in a very professional manner and efficient. I personally would like to thank Miss Claire Redstone for been an amazing agent
Mr · 16 August 2023
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotMegan was fantastic and made our job in…
Megan was fantastic and made our job in finalising an apartment to move in easier. Responses to my emails were dealt timely and she helped us in the process of sorting out everything.
Ayan · 26 November 2020
Agent replied · 13 June 2024
Thank you for your kind words, it was a pleasure to able to assist you. We hope to hear from you in the future.
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotEllen Lutwyche is someone I have never…
Ellen Lutwyche is someone I have never set my eyes on before. But, always put a smile on my face each time I contact her about any issue concerning our accommodation. She is so patient, understanding and a solution finder. The world would be a better place if we have more of her.
Olaiya · 25 October 2022
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotGreat customer service
Both Drew and Melissa have been amazing extremely helpful I felt very sorry for drew with my constant bothering but he done amazingly under so much pressure and thank you to Melissa who’s helped out massively when our washer dryer went down both a credit to the John Sheppard company
Sam · 8 February 2023
★★★★★ 1/5
TrustpilotWe have been fatally scammed and ruined
We have been fatally scammed by this "agency". WE DO WARN EVERYONE before proceeding with them, as the problems never arise before signing the contract. It has been an absolute nightmare since barely a year ago decided to move somewhere else. Our minimum stay was over by then. They have completely stolen our deposit, leaving us in a critical financial situation after having a baby and both of us lost our jobs because of Covid. As an example, they quoted £900 for a job that can be easily done for £100 (we indeed found many contractors that can prove this). We have been completely helpless.Please, stay away from these unethical and heartless people, they can ruin your life as they did to us.
L · 1 February 2021
Agent replied · 13 June 2024
Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review, we’re sorry to hear your experience has not been as we’d hope at this point. We are very keen to speak directly to understand more specifically what the issues you have experienced are and how we can rectify them. Please email our Lettings Director at jack.spellman@johnshepherd.com and he will be happy to discuss more. Many thanks
★★★★★ 5/5
Trustpilotcommercial sale
This was a complicated sale due to sitting tenants. Katie & Natasha were professional at all times. Their marketing strategies were excellent and their commitment in somewhat difficult circumstances was faultless. I recommend them unreservedly. Many thanks Natasha & Katie.
Barry · 6 November 2023
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotJack Richardson was brilliant
Jack Richardson looked after us from start to finish and really made us feel comfortable from the get go. Attentive, thoughtful, easy to get in with and always able to answer questions - we’d highly recommend him. He is always prompt to get back which goes a long way during such stressful times! And he has a wealth of contacts to match his knowledge - we were overly impressed with the mortgage broker he chose to recommend too.You can go wrong with this company if Jack as a leading example is anything to go by - nothing to fault from our experience!
Gary · 12 November 2020
Agent replied · 13 June 2024
Thank you for your kind words, it was a pleasure to able to assist you. We hope to hear from you in the future.
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotThe first thing which stood out with…
The first thing which stood out with John shepherd was how quick they were finding a viewing of the apartment i was interested in and that it was the ONLY Estate agent i went through where the place looked exactly like the pictures listed on the website.The viewing was done by Megan who was lovely and very easy to talk to. I told her i was interested in the place and she explained the steps in order to take it very clear and was quick to start the process that evening.It was my first time moving out so i had a lot of questions however she was quick to answer each one and helped me out with any enquiries or confusions i had with the moving in process, such as explaining the contracts, how the bills are done etc. It was so smooth moving out thanks to her support and now I'm 2 weeks into my residency and she is still consistently and efficiently helping me out with any problems or questions i have thanks to how easy she is to talk to.
Martyn · 12 November 2020
Agent replied · 13 June 2024
Thank you for your kind words, it was a pleasure to able to assist you. We hope to hear from you in the future.
★★★★★ 4/5
TrustpilotProfessional staff, awful referencing processes.
The agents in the company are really professional and helpful. It was really easy to book a viewing for the property. The hard part is when the referencing started, it was the worst experience in my life. They are using the services of a third party company called Uktenantdata. The referencing process is unreasonably over complicated, them asking unrelated and very intrusive question, it felt like harassment at one point. It is easier and faster to get a mortgage than to deal with Uktenantdata, so be ready for that. Feedback from the company: ditch that company and find yourself a better partner company, they are awful.
Emil · 8 October 2020
Agent replied · 13 June 2024
Hi Emil, Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts with us. We have noted your concern regarding our third party company and will address this moving forward and apologises for any inconvenience caused on their behalf. This platform is for John Shepherd as a business, if you were satisfied with John Shepherd as a whole and the received service from our team members we would appreciate this to be reflected in the star rating. Thank you
★★★★★ 1/5
TrustpilotI Phoned 3 times to enquire about a…
My boyfriend phoned 3 times to enquire about a property, twice the phone was picked up and then we had the phone put down on us before had chance to speak, on the 3rd attempt, a girl called Emily answered, and abruptly said “Property has gone, any changes and will let you know” Before the word know was finished, Emily put the phone down without him even getting a word in
Millie · 28 August 2024
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotAmazing service
Great service and made the stressful experience of the buying much easier. Thanks to Lauren and Harry for arranging to drop the keys off to us on completion taking away the stress of another job on the day.
Mr · 30 October 2023
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotLauren Wood
I would like to express my appreciation of the superb level of support provided by Lauren Wood on our property in recent months in difficult circumstances.Lauren has been extremely pro-active in trying to resolve all matters as quickly as possible.Thank you very much Lauren.
Richard · 19 May 2023
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotI can't recommend this company enough!
I can't recommend this company enough. The whole team has been nothing short of angels. They made a very complex move possible and we as a family will be forever greatful.
Lara · 18 December 2025
★★★★★ 4/5
TrustpilotGreat help and support
Thank you for turning a bad experience into a positive one. These days it seems that landlords often get the raw end of the deal but when you have an sympathetic ear hearing your concerns and working with you it really helps. Jonny Evans and Rajak Ali from the Sutton Coldfield office have been great - a big shout out to them and Samantha Follows too. Thanks again!
Janet · 2 October 2024
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotFriendly, Fast, First Time Buying.
Jack was super fast in contacting us. He was so friendly and easy to talk to, as well as being very informative and helpful. Although we didn’t end up buying, we still can’t recommend them enough. Loads of free helpful advice and resources available for first time buyers, explained in a way that really helped me understand the mortgage process.
Eleanor · 1 March 2021
★★★★★ 5/5
TrustpilotThanks for the service Megan
Megan was not just helpful, she was professional and had good customer service. She had good communication and always tried to understand, very collected and all round fantastic service.
Israel · 26 November 2020
Agent replied · 13 June 2024
Thank you for your kind words, it was a pleasure to able to assist you. We hope to hear from you in the future.
Where the same review appears twice we show it once. We leave out reviews that name another agent or another of the brand's offices.