Trusted Agent profile

Property Genius reviews

3.7

★★★★★ Good

100 reviews across 2 platforms

424 Barlow Moor Road, Chorlton Cum Hardy, Manchester M21 8AD

Property Genius's Manchester office at 424 Barlow Moor Road is rated 3.7 out of 5 across 100 reviews on two platforms, including 38 Google reviews rated 3.9. Checked 9 October 2026.

Google logo

3.9 / 5

38

Reviews on Google

This office

Trustpilot logo

62

Reviews on Trustpilot

This office

Reviews may appear on more than one platform.

Reviews

Every review we hold for the Manchester office, from every platform, shown as written. First names only.

2/5

Google

The smallest regard to tenant satisfaction & condescending customer service. Rented with Property Genius for around 1 year and had numerous instances of condescending customer service skills from Vicki and the owner Graeme. It was mainly just their mannerisms & wording, wasn't anything close to being warm or friendly but rather self centred and patronising. Charged us for an electrician being called out to the property to identify where the fusebox was IN THEIR OWN PROPERTY THAT THEY MANAGE - unbelievable, as a property management company should know this on file. After plenty of kicking and screaming from them, they finally agreed to go halves on the cost which I do respect, but it should not take what it took for this to happen and really they should've paid it in full. I am largely leaving this review since they charged me a whopping cleaning fee, with the extractor fan being apart of this fee. Literally was in the same condition upon moving in - I kinda found it to just be a money grab as a last laugh from them if anything. Just quite a petty company altogether, but my landlady was lovely though, so that I can say :)

Josef · 16 May 2024

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. We value all feedback, both positive and negative. However, we must express that our team encountered significant challenges with abusive language and threats during communications, which complicated our efforts to assist effectively. Regarding the issue with the electrician, we typically advise tenants to check straightforward solutions like the consumer unit to help avoid unnecessary service charges. The issue was caused by a toaster being left on the hob causing a significant fire hazard. The decision to split the cost of the call out was an effort to resolve the matter cooperatively, and foster a positive way to move forward. The cleaning fee was a directive from the landlord, not a decision made by us to generate additional revenue. We do not benefit financially from works assigned to contractors. We appreciate your kind remarks about the landlady and are glad to hear that aspect of your experience was positive. While we always strive for constructive interactions, we encourage all parties to engage respectfully to resolve any issues effectively. Thank you again for your feedback, which will help us continue to improve our services. We wish you the best in your future housing experiences.

1/5

Trustpilot

Avoid at all costs

My experience with this agency has been extremely dissapointing. Tenant welfare does not appear to be a priority, they are willing to overlook, and at times enable, inappropriate and exploitative behaviour from landlords. I experienced situations where the landlord’s conduct crossed clear boundaries, yet meaningful intervention only occurred after I repeatedly escalated the issue.

B · 9 June 2026

Agent replied · 24 September 2026

We are disappointed that you continue to misrepresent the circumstances surrounding the end of your tenancy. Property Genius was not responsible for the ongoing management of this property and had no authority to determine whether any deduction should or should not be made from your tenancy deposit. As you acknowledge, the tenancy deposit itself was returned through the TDS custodial scheme. Any discussions regarding proposed deductions took place directly between yourself and the landlord. Property Genius did not impose any deduction upon you. When concerns were raised regarding the process, we responded to your correspondence and sought to assist in bringing the matter to a conclusion. At no point did Property Genius pressure you to accept any proposal, nor did we prevent you from referring any dispute to the tenancy deposit scheme’s formal adjudication process. We reject the allegation that we enabled unfair practice or acted improperly. We are also unaware of any finding by the TDS, a court, a local authority, or any other independent body that supports the serious allegations contained in this review. As the matters relate to a former tenancy and involve third-party correspondence, we do not intend to discuss the matter further in a public forum.

1/5

Google

Absolutely no regard for renters, multiple maintenance requests not dealt with or only dealt with as urgent once the neighbours got involved as they felt they were in danger. We were quite literally left without a shower for 6 weeks and no compensation for our trouble offered. Staff often rude and sarcastic during communications and absolutely rinsed us of an entire deposit with little grounds or proof of original condition. Attempted to increase rent by £250 a month at the turn of the year. Would genuinely avoid any property 'managed' by this agent. Managed is a strong word in any case. Only consolation was a member of staff who was helpful when we first moved in and unfortunately left the company - not at all surprised.

Joss · 18 November 2023

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Dear Joss, Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We always aim to deliver a great experience, and we apologise if we fell short in your case. Regarding the maintenance requests, we maintain detailed records of all tenant communications and actions taken. Our audit logs show that during your two-year tenancy, we addressed 11 raised issues, including repairing a washing machine and fixing a leaking shower, which admittedly took longer than expected due to structural damage. We understand that delays can be frustrating, and we strive to resolve issues as swiftly as possible. We deeply regret any instances where our communication may have come across as unsatisfactory. Providing courteous and professional service is paramount to us. Regarding the deposit, we adhere to a rigorous and transparent process. The property’s condition at the end of the tenancy, as documented with photographs and signed off in the inventory, was significantly different from the initial state. We removed 15 bags of waste, replaced stained mattresses, addressed extensive garden neglect and cleaning. The deductions were calculated in line with TDS guidance, and we provided a detailed proposal with evidence for transparency. 3rd party arbitration was offered, but not taken. The rent increase was in response to the landlord's request due to rising mortgage costs for her and remained below market value. We appreciate that changes in rent can be challenging, and we always aim to balance the interests of our tenants and landlords. We value your feedback as it helps us improve our service. If there are any unresolved issues or specific instances you’d like to discuss further, please feel free to reach out to us directly. Our goal is to ensure a positive experience for all our tenants and landlords.

1/5

Trustpilot

Very rigid referencing system that…

Very rigid referencing system that seems heavily biased toward conventional salaried employment only. Despite providing substantial savings/investment evidence and full cooperation throughout the process, affordability was still rejected without a guarantor and the holding deposit was retained. Difficult experience for anyone in a transitional situation such as training, returning from abroad, or non-standard income.

A · 12 May 2026

Agent replied · 31 May 2026

Hi Alexander, Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback and I'm sorry to hear that you found the process frustrating. We fully appreciate that applicants with non-traditional income arrangements, career transitions, or upcoming training placements can find standard referencing criteria challenging. Unfortunately, as letting agents, we are required to follow the affordability and referencing requirements set by both the landlord and independent referencing provider. In this case, it's a condition of the landlords insurance provider that we obtain an 'accept' reference. In this case, your application was not declined outright. Following the initial assessment, we reopened the referencing process at your request and submitted the additional documentation provided for further review. After reassessment, the application remained subject to a guarantor requirement due to the affordability outcome returned by the referencing provider. We also discussed alternative options available to help proceed with the tenancy, including third-party guarantor services, and these options remain available should you still wish to continue with the application.

1/5

Google

While we were initially impressed with the process of signing up through property genius, having now been a tenant of one of their landlords for several months we are more aware of the quality of service Property Genius provide. It took a month to fix a problem with our heating (in February!), they've also been actively avoiding dealing with ventilation problems at the property, so much so we had to get the council involved. When it comes to dealing with the landlord they enable illegal behaviour (not providing enough heating in occupied rooms). I appreciate our landlord is not brilliant but as an intermediary it's their job to at least ensure minimum legal standards are met, we have children at the property but still they're not interested in tackling problems. I have gone through Property Genius's complaints process, with no success. Our living room heater is still unable to heat the property when it's cold, this is illegal but PG have closed our repair request and are refusing to act further on it. Our shower is acting up, the shower is not suitable for the water pressure at the flat, it's been a month of on-and-off cold showers and no sign of a fix yet, and no communication at all from PG for two weeks. Fortunately I can recommend Trafford Council Environmental Health team who have been supportive in helping get items fixed. It's also worth noting that our landlord is listed below having left a five star review.. to be clear, we have not been comfortable, our needs have not been addressed and we have not had a good experience letting the property.

James · 16 June 2023

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

We are sorry to hear about your negative experience with our services. However, we feel the need to clarify a few points mentioned in your review. Firstly, we would like to assure you that we take our responsibilities seriously, and we always strive to provide the best possible service to our tenants. We acknowledge that there were issues with your heating and ventilation, and we apologize for any inconvenience caused. We have worked hard to address these issues, and we have replaced the heaters and are working on replacing the extractor fan in the bathroom. Regarding the broken blind, we are waiting for the landlord to fix it, and we are following up on this. Additionally, the contractor is speaking with the manufacturer regarding the shower temperature issue, and we are trying to resolve this as soon as possible. Furthermore, we would like to emphasize that we do not condone any illegal behavior from our landlords. We always ensure that our landlords meet the minimum legal standards, and we take appropriate action if there is any violation. We take all complaints seriously and are a member of the property ombudsman. We have a comprehensive complaints process that we encourage our tenants to use if they have any issues or concerns. We understand that you may be frustrated with the situation, but we assure you that we have been working hard to resolve the issues you have mentioned. We hope that we can work together to improve your experience and that you will consider revising your review in light of our efforts.

5/5

Trustpilot

Excellent, Trustworthy landlords Team ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐

I have been with Property Genius for several years, and I honestly couldn’t ask for a better letting agent. They have consistently found excellent tenants for my properties, making the whole process smooth, stress-free, and professionally managed from start to finish.

Mohammad · 1 July 2026

Agent replied · 24 September 2026

Thank you so much! Your support over the years really does mean a lot to all of us. It’s been a pleasure working with you, and we’re grateful for the trust you’ve placed in our team. We look forward to continuing to look after your properties for many years to come. Thanks again!

5/5

Trustpilot

Property Genius are great

Renting is scary and intimidating, but Property Genius make the process easy and straightforward. They have brilliant customer service and keep on top of everything. I've felt supported every step of the way. Fantastic service.

Amber · 13 May 2025

Agent replied · 27 July 2025

Thank you so much for your kind words and for taking the time to leave such a thoughtful review! We’re really pleased to hear that you felt supported and that we helped make the renting process feel less daunting. It’s something we work hard on as we know how overwhelming it can sometimes be, especially in today’s market. Your feedback means a lot to us and we’re delighted to have made a positive difference. Best wishes, Graeme & the Property Genius Team

4/5

Google

Ella was the nicest estate agent we met as she didn't put pressure on us and was very friendly and professional. Graeme support us to sort out all our paperwork which was a bit intensive with all the checks but he helped to make the process as easy as possible. We also got a lovely welcome box when we moved in. We love our new flat, thank you!

Katharine · 16 June 2023

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you for taking the time to leave us such a wonderful review! We are thrilled to hear that we provided you with a friendly and professional service, without putting any pressure on you during the letting process. We always strive to make the experience as easy as possible for our clients, and we are glad to hear that we were able to make it a smooth process for you. We are delighted to hear that you are enjoying your new flat and we hope that it feels like a home to you. We always aim to provide a high standard of service to our clients, and the welcome box is just one of the ways we like to show our appreciation for choosing us as your letting agent. Once again, thank you for choosing us as your letting agent and for leaving such a lovely review. We hope that you will continue to enjoy your new home and if you need any further assistance in the future, please do not hesitate to contact us.

5/5

Trustpilot

I would highly recommend Property Genius …

I would highly recommend Property Genius to anyone out there needing an efficient and effective service. Graeme and the team work tirelessly to provide a wonderful service and take the pressure away from day to day work.

Alan · 30 December 2024

Agent replied · 27 July 2025

Thank you so much for taking the time to leave such a wonderful review! We’re pleased that our team could help take some of the pressure off to help you.

5/5

Google

Amazing guys, Graeme is doing a fantastic job at keeping the company quick to respond and reliable in all means, I've been with many other agencies and due to their larger size they provide a much worse service than Property Genius

Artur · 28 July 2024

Agent replied · 24 August 2024

Thank you so much for your kind words and the 5-star review! We’re thrilled to hear that you’ve had such a positive experience. We really do our best to provide quick and reliable service, so when this is felt and acknowledged, it really means a lot. Thank you 🙏 …

5/5

Trustpilot

Excellent Lettings Service from Start to Finish

I have recently let my property through Property Genius and have been extremely impressed with the service from start to finish.

Shawcroft · 9 June 2026

Agent replied · 24 December 2025

Thank you so much for taking the time to leave such a lovely review. It was a pleasure helping you let your property, and we’re delighted to hear that you felt informed and supported throughout the process. Vicki will be especially pleased to read your kind words! Thank you again for your trust and recommendation. We wish you and your tenants all the very best, and we’re always here if you need us in the future.

4/5

Trustpilot

Viewing with Graeme

Hi. Viewed a property with Graeme. The property didn’t look like the images posted on Right Move. The overall decoration & fittings were very tired & worn. The kitchen looks like it needs a really good clean or possible replacement as the shelves inside the units were poor. The fridge freezer was rusty inside too. There was a tile missing in the hallway under the rad cover and the carpets throughout were either threadbare or torn. All of the paintwork looked like it needed a good soap scrub & lick of paint. The Best room was the loft!

TRACEY · 7 January 2018

Agent replied · 14 June 2024

Thank you for sharing your feedback, it's very much appreciated. Just a bit of background with this - the previous tenant of the property, unfortunately, left in a very bad state before Christmas. Contractors were in the process of remedying the issues, but in the interest of reducing the void period for the landlord and costing her more in loss of rent, we started advertising before the work was complete.

5/5

Google

"I can't thank my letting agent enough for their exceptional service! From start to finish, they made the entire renting process smooth and stress-free. Their professionalism, attention to detail, and prompt communication truly set them apart. They go above and beyond to ensure everything runs smoothly and always make me feel valued as a tenant. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a reliable, friendly, and dedicated team!"

Kazem · 4 March 2025

Agent replied · 12 April 2025

Thank you so much for your kind words and fantastic 5-star review! We’re delighted to hear that you’ve had such a positive experience with our team. We really appreciate your recommendation and look forward to continuing to support you throughout your tenancy.

5/5

Google

Best letting agency. Application process was really smooth, easy and fast. Throughout the application process Graeme was quick to reply to any question we faced. Again thank you so much Property Genius.

Kshitiz · 20 August 2024

Agent replied · 24 August 2024

Thank you so much for your fantastic review! We’re thrilled to hear that you found the application process a breeze, and proud we could make your experience a positive one. We truly appreciate your kind words and wish you all the joy in your new home!

5/5

Trustpilot

My Investment

Vicki is efficient in her management of my property, both during the letting period and finding suitable tenants at the end of the tenancy. I am confident that my investment is in safe hands with Property Genius.

Carl · 25 May 2024

Agent replied · 14 June 2024

Thank you for your fantastic review! We’re thrilled to hear that you’ve had a positive experience with Vicki and our team. It’s great to know you feel confident in our management of your property. Your kind words and trust mean a lot to us.

5/5

Trustpilot

My Investment

Vicki is efficient in her management of my property, both during the letting period and finding suitable tenants at the end of the tenancy.

Carl · 25 May 2024

Agent replied · 14 June 2024

Thank you for your fantastic review! We’re thrilled to hear that you’ve had a positive experience with Vicki and our team. It’s great to know you feel confident in our management of your property. Your kind words and trust mean a lot to us.

5/5

Trustpilot

Exemplary service from our estate agent!

Agent was immediately on the case, even in the late evening. Contractors came quickly, did a great job, and a plan of action was formulated. Good communication, and Graeme was great at keeping me calm and level-headed through what was doubtlessly a stressful experience.

JR · 29 December 2022

Agent replied · 14 June 2024

Thank you for taking the time to write your review! I'm glad we got your major leak sorted.

5/5

Trustpilot

Highly recommended! …

Property Genius manage our rental property and have been wonderful from the start. Communication has been great and they really have made it a stress free and easy journey. Highly recommended!

Kate · 5 September 2025

Agent replied · 24 December 2025

Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your recommendation means a great deal to us!

1/5

Google

I felt that my query was pushed to one side, and they did their best to get me off of the phone. They wasn't considerate for what I had to say, I was speaking to someone called Vicky from the Lettings team. I felt it was quite ignorant and just wanted to make that clear for anyone else that may have a slightly more unique query. Sorry to have to leave this review but I was wanting an email for a higher up representative and she refused to provide this to me.

Serena · 16 June 2023

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

I’m sorry you feel this way. We’d already spoken before in June 2022. We understand you work for a company that creates ‘corporate’ tenancy agreements which then sublets out the property, for a markup, to your clients which could include but not limited to AirBnb/serviced accommodation/refugees/temporary housing for councils. We explained our client has said they would not be interested in an arrangement like this, and I’m sorry this wasn’t the answer you were hoping.

5/5

Google

For over 12 years Property Genius has Let and Managed 2 of my properties. As a Landlord they have taken the 'load of my shoulder' and provided a full management service to date. Their service has been exceptional in looking after my investments and taking care of the tenants - ensuring that they are comfortable, their needs are addressed promptly and that they have a good experience whilst renting the properties. Property Genius has performed above the call of duty - when there was an issue with one of my properties, during a void period without a tenant, the Owner, of Property Genius, drove a fare distance from where he resides, late into the evening, to address the issue at the property. I would highly recommend to Landlords to use the services of Property Genius and for Tenants you are in safe hands when your rental is being managed by Property Genius !

Carl · 16 June 2023

Agent replied · 15 June 2024

Thank you for taking the time to write and express your gratitude for our services over the past 12+ years. We appreciate your loyalty and trust in Property Genius as your Letting and Management agent. Vicki & I are also grateful for your understanding of the situation with the current tenant and your defense of our business. It is reassuring to hear that our efforts to provide excellent service have not gone unnoticed and that we have met your expectations. We strive to deliver exceptional service to all our clients and to maintain long-term relationships based on trust, transparency, and professionalism. Your favorable comment is greatly appreciated and will help us to continue to provide top-notch service to our clients. We look forward to serving you for many more years to come and maintaining our strong partnership. Once again, thank you for your kind words and your continued support.

1/5

Trustpilot

Rang up to enquire about a property for…

Rang up to enquire about a property for let, asked if the landlord has stipulated whether pets were allowed in this property to be told there wasn’t any information on this, when asked if there was any way to communicate with the landlord to find out whether pets were allowed or not I was told that if a landlord does not state their stance on pets in the property they are to assume it is a no, when i informed them that the property i am living in at the moment didn’t stipulate whether pets could live in the property or not (resulted in the landlord agreeing to a pet), i was told to please hold whilst she asked the property manager, who in less time than it took for me to take my phone from my ear to check the time, had informed the agent i was speaking to it was in-fact no pets allowed, i then questioned how this was discussed in less than 3-4 seconds, and why the property manager would have different information to the agent who would be holding the property viewings and receiving enquiries about the property, to be told that the reason the property manager has this information and the agent i was speaking to did not was due to the fact that they are the property manager (I would’ve assumed the property manager would want to communicate all information on a property to let to the agents who will be holding the viewings but i guess not, and I should also assume the property manager passed on this information telepathically due to the record breaking speed they communicated) Most letting agents require this information from landlords prior to putting a house up for let, so for one agent to tell me that the landlord never said yes or no to pets, and for another agent to have informed them that they infact listed it as no pets seems semi-unprofessional, and may be the reason this letting agent seems to have a mixed set of reviews in its communication and experience from current tenants, looks like I may have had a lucky break.

K.Mc · 7 September 2022

Agent replied · 14 June 2024

Hello, I’m sorry this has been your experience, but can certainly offer an explanation. My colleague who answered your call was sat directly opposite the property manager who looks after this property and has the close relationship with the landlord. Sat only 6 feet away, she was able to provide an answer to your enquiry was quickly, though I’m sorry the answer was not what you hoped for. We love pets, we really do, and wish every property was able to have a furry friend. However in this case the landlord has had a bad experience and rejected previous offers from people who had pets. This decision is not ours, but the landlords, and I’m sorry your opinion on this is reflected in your review here. Best of luck with your continued search.

5/5

Trustpilot

Very professional

Very professional, punctual, very approachable, knowledgeable and great asset to help customers with all they need. I personally dealt with Graeme, who’s walked me through the course to Buy and subsequently to Let the same property. Impeccable service. I’d strongly recommend PROPERTY GENIUS to family & friends….Zahid Badul

Zahid · 1 March 2018

Agent replied · 14 June 2024

Really pleased to hear Zahid!

5/5

Trustpilot

Recommended

Having recently changed Managing Agent to Property Genius I am very happy with the service so far. Very efficient and signed up a new tenant promptly cutting down on void period. Thoroughly recommended and a vast improvement on previous Agent.

Don · 18 January 2025

Agent replied · 27 July 2025

Thank you so much for your kind words and for taking the time to leave us a review! We’re delighted to hear that you’re happy with our service and to know we’ve made a positive impression compared to your previous agent. Your recommendation means a great deal to us.

1/5

Trustpilot

This agency is a disgrace we have been…

This agency is a disgrace we have been left for over a year with damp issuss at a flat we rent on urmston lane still waiting for this to be sorted bed room had bad damp and so dose the living room we have a 5month old baby living in a damp property and the ageny do not care at all but they are happy to take the rent money every month without fail we have now been left 4 days with no heating and hot water after the boiler broke we are still waitng for heating and hot water we have a 5month old baby and are in winter with all the stormes we habe just been having aswell disgracful we cant wait for our crontract to end in a years time so we can get the hell out of this place and this agency

Daniel · 21 February 2022

Agent replied · 14 June 2024

Concerning issues raised with dampness within the property, an Officer from Regulatory Services of Tameside Council visited the property on 1 November 2021 and was accompanied by a representative of the company. During that visit of almost an hour long, the officer established that the dampness within the property was a result of condensation, most likely caused by lifestyle (It was noted wet clothes were left on all raditors with no ventalation among other issues) and the high cost of the electric heating installed within the property. The Officer therefore provided advice to you about how to reduce the build-up of condensation dampness within the property, as well as electricity tariffs and the use of a direct debit to pay you utility company. As no deficiencies with the property were identified by the Officer that were giving rise to a damp and mould growth hazard, it was deemed that no further action could be taken by the Council, or any aciton possible by the landlord/agency and the case has therefore been closed on their system. Following your email on the 14th December 2021 explaining your dissatisfation with Officer's assessment, we offered to end your tenacy, free of charge, just let us know an end date so we can relist the property, but as of yet this offer has not yet been taken up. Concerning issues raised with the boiler, the parts needed were on order with a wait time of 2-10 days. Thankfully this is being repaired/installed tomorrow after 6 days wait. An offer to put you and your family in a hotel was also, not taken up. I'm sorry you feel we've fallen short here, but we have offered you everything possible.

Where the same review appears twice we show it once. We leave out reviews that name another agent or another of the brand's offices.

Read Property Genius's Google reviews

Questions about Property Genius

How many reviews does Property Genius have?

Property Genius's Manchester office has 100 reviews across two platforms: 38 on Google, 62 on Trustpilot. Reviews may appear on more than one platform. Checked 9 October 2026.

What is Property Genius's rating?

Property Genius is rated 3.7 out of 5 across all 100 reviews, and 3.9 out of 5 on Google from 38 reviews, checked 9 October 2026.

Where is Property Genius's Manchester office?

Property Genius, 424 Barlow Moor Road, Chorlton Cum Hardy, Manchester M21 8AD.

The Trusted Agent

Ratings and review counts checked 9 October 2026. Is this your office? Claim your page.