Trusted Agent profile · Edinburgh

Lindsays Edinburgh reviews

3.8

★★★★★ Good

143 reviews across 2 platforms

Caledonian Exchange, 19A Canning Street, Edinburgh, EH3 8HE

Lindsays's office in Edinburgh, at Caledonian Exchange, is rated 3.8 out of 5 across 143 reviews on two platforms, including 77 Google reviews rated 3.7.

Google logo

3.7 / 5

77

Reviews on Google

This office

Trustpilot logo

66

Reviews on Trustpilot

Business-wide

Reviews may appear on more than one platform.

Reviews

Every review we hold for the Edinburgh office, from every platform, shown as written. First names only.

5/5

Trustpilot

I had a great experience with Ben from Lindsays

I had a great experience with Ben from Lindsays, regarding employment law. He was knowledgeable and reassuring, and generously spoke to me about quite a lot of the details of my case before even discussing fees. Ben's advise was practical and well explained, and I couldn't be happier.

Graeme · 23 December 2025

5/5

Trustpilot

Excellent communication and patience

I would recommend Lindsay’s after they dealt with the selling of our house. Communication was excellent and everything was clearly explained to us. Our case was a little complicated but nothing was too much trouble and Emma’s patience is to be commended. Would definitely use again.

Joanna · 5 May 2024

5/5

Google

The quality of the work was excellent in the preparation of Wills for me and my wife. A little frustration at times trying to contact Nicole Noble, but this most likely tells us that the very good people are the very busy people and one has to accept being one of many live clients!

Walter · 16 October 2025

1/5

Google

We sold to a buyer being represented by Lindsays. Our buyer concluded missives months ago. We felt reassured that a reputable firm were acting for him and assumed they would have checked to make sure their clients had enough funds to fullfill his contractual obligations and complete the sale. Unfortunately that was a misplaced sense of reassurance since their client did not in fact have the money, nor anywhere close to the amount of money, required to complete the sale. This has left a chain of enormous losses and 3 families in a state of limbo the month before Christmas. I would never accept another buyer who has anything to do with this law firm in future.

DrDarrenMcKeown · 19 November 2024

1/5

Trustpilot

If I could give zero I would

If I could give zero I would this guy let me get disqualified from driving after I’d already been done for the same driving offence he failed to mention to the court I’d had my licence revoked for the exact same offence basically double jeopardy rule and I’m now trying to get it all sorted out not a good thing about them the receptionist is rude and abrupt too

James · 9 March 2025

5/5

Google

I live in the states. I worked with Nicole Noble and Patricia Adams, both of whom handled my late Aunt’s case with dignity. I appreciated the effort of Ms.Adams in sending me per my request, documents at a certain time of the month which was paramount in my situation. I highly recommend this agency.

Bonnie · 12 June 2023

5/5

Trustpilot

Excellent attention to detail and diligence

We really appreciated the diligence, attention to detail and communication from Amanda Frenz at Lindsays during our house purchase.

Jen · 9 June 2026

1/5

Trustpilot

Uncommunicative, difficult to get hold of, slow. Will not use again

Feb 2024.Along the lines of similar reviews. Poor communication. General feeling they’re not actually doing anything to earn the money. Unable to easily contact the person who is dealing with our transactions. Mother’s estate, the easiest to wrap up still waiting after many months. Solictors letter to a company who had incorrect information on us, cost an arm and a leg. I have used Shield and Kyd since 1993 before they merged into Lindsay’s and they were great. Once our current transaction is completed, We will not be using Lindsays for anything.Update. August 2024. Still waiting for completion of mothers estate. This has been nearly a year. Problems…. ineptitude, people forgetting to do things and process paperwork, maternity leave. Handovers not completed properly. Holidays. Lost track of who is now dealing with this transaction. An absolute nightmare.

JC · 26 August 2024

1/5

Trustpilot

Dreadful company

My first and last experience of this dreadful company was as negative as one can imagine.

GROOVYCHIC · 16 June 2026

4/5

Google

I was pleased with the estate agency services provided by Lindsays. The initial contact with Tracy gave us great pointers on presentation and pricing of the property. Then the service provided by Reena, our point of contact, and the rest of the team including Una, Gemma, Roberta, Alison and Heather who kept us up to date on viewings, feedback and developments. Useful advice on the selling process and prompt response to queries. Thank you.

Linda · 2 November 2024

5/5

Trustpilot

Excellent communication and service.

I required an update to my will and had the pleasure of assistance from Samera Ali who was thoroughly professional but still friendly. My wishes were translated into an official document with little need for any amendments. Communication was excellent and the whole process was completed in very short time.

Bruce · 22 August 2025

5/5

Trustpilot

Lindsays were excellent!

Lindsays proved very reliable and trustworthy when dealing with our recent house sale and purchase.

H.Pollock · 3 June 2026

1/5

Google

Incompetent solicitor firm. AML checks carried out on a buyer 6 days before a 4 party chain was due to complete. The buyer failed the checks, leaving mine and 3 other families in a difficult situation. It’s ridiculous that these checks were carried out so late in the transaction and my own solicitor confirmed that it categorically should not happen. I would never use Lindsay’s and I wouldn’t accept a buyer who is using Lindsay’s, after this experience.

Jack · 8 June 2024

1/5

Google

Shocking experience, was quoted £1000 to £1500 for a simple divorce and after only 2 weeks the lawyer passed it to her intern as if she couldn't be bothered with us, I paid the £1500 plus another £100 and to my horror I received another invoice for over £2700 once my divorce was through after being quoted £1500 for my full divorce process minus a couple hundred pounds here or there if additional paperwork was needed, these charges are obscene, stay away from this company as bills appear and are fabricated from nowhere, I'm now having to goto court to fight this, but no matter what happens I will not pay it I wil go bankrupt before I do, I have nothing to loose

Davy · 10 April 2024

1/5

Trustpilot

Absolutely horrendous experience with…

Absolutely horrendous experience with this lot if I could give no stars I would, was quoted between £1000 and £1500 for a simple divorce got the impression the first lawyer (Alison mckee) couldn't be arsed I paid the £1500 that I was quoted and she switched it to her graduate (Claire brown) then at the end of it I was hit with another invoice for £2736 so they basically want me to pay for the same thing twice, they are con artists and like the other reviews on here seems to be a pattern they invent bills out of nowhere, the lawyer couldn't be bothered passed it to a intern and cracked up my bill while she overlooked my case from time to time, absolutely shocking company, I refuse to pay and I'm now having to goto court over this

Davy · 3 April 2024

2/5

Google

Do not buy or sell a property through Lindsay’s. Couldn’t have been less interested or less commercial if they had tried….ridiculous bill for many mistakes……terrible.

Brian · 16 February 2026

5/5

Trustpilot

Outstanding service great communication

Outstanding service. When we needed to speak with our Solicitor Lindsay Carr the communication was very easy. Lindsay always called back if we left a message on her voicemail within the hour. Clear communication via email in both selling our existing house and purchasing our new one. Just outstanding customer service.

Craig · 6 June 2025

5/5

Google

I had the help of Reena Koli to sell my flat and the help she gave me got a higher price than I was expecting. Great service and kept me in the loop every step of the way and took care of all the viewings and paperwork. Great service

Lewis · 16 June 2025

5/5

Trustpilot

My experience with Lindsays

I visited Lindsays in order to alter my existing Will, the business being attended to by Samera Ali. The transaction by her was conducted in a friendly and most professional and efficient manner. Thoroughly recommended.

Alan · 28 October 2025

5/5

Trustpilot

Samera Ali arranged administration of…

Samera Ali arranged administration of my mother's will. All steps and processes were explained clearly in a friendly, professional manner. Communication was timeous and comprehensive. I would have no hesitation in recommending Samera or contacting her for future legal business.

Gerry · 4 September 2025

5/5

Trustpilot

Unfair dismissal

Used Lindsays for an employment dispute. Ben Doherty was knowledgeable, professional and very helpful. Always quick to respond to any questions and very approachable. I can highly recommend Ben Doherty/Lindsay’s.

Johannes · 11 March 2024

5/5

Google

In the process of selling my flat through Lindsays and they have been great so far. They've made the process as straightforward as possible and have given me excellent advice and guidance. Nicola Scott and Heather Archibald have been selling my property and have been great to work with.

Mark · 19 May 2025

1/5

Google

Not recommended. The agency is misrepresenting the property prices in order to secure a higher amount for their client.

Anna · 16 February 2026

1/5

Trustpilot

not recommended

We were buying and selling a house with Lindsay, and I must state that choosing Lindsay was a big mistake.

DS · 19 July 2024

Where the same review appears twice we show it once. We leave out reviews that name another agent or another of the brand's offices.

Read Lindsays's Google reviews

Questions about Lindsays Edinburgh

How many reviews does Lindsays Edinburgh have?

Lindsays's Edinburgh office has 143 reviews across two platforms: 77 on Google, 66 on Trustpilot (across the whole business).

What is Lindsays Edinburgh's rating?

Lindsays Edinburgh is rated 3.8 out of 5 across all 143 reviews, and 3.7 out of 5 on Google from 77 reviews.

Where is Lindsays's Edinburgh office?

Lindsays Edinburgh, Caledonian Exchange, 19A Canning Street, Edinburgh, EH3 8HE.

The Trusted Agent

Is this your office? Claim your page.