Martin & Co Sheffield reviews

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

Martin and Co Allerton road

Martin and Co Allerton road, been messed around for over 3 days trying to view one of there property’s, first one called up and viewing cancelled due to tenants not left property. Then was rearranged for following Monday was then called and was asked to confirm my viewing but not for the agreed rearranged time, so viewing cancelled again then rearranged again for the same time following day. So had no phone call to confirm or any contact from agents following day I assumed everything was ok gets to property and yes exactly what I thought nobody there for my viewing. Calls the branch to be told I had cancelled on there system absolutely diabolical customer service never have I dealt with a company so incompetent, avoid them for lettings can’t comment and on sales team but not a very good experience at all.

Colin · 28 October 2020

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

Martin & co pontefract disgrace !

Martin & co pontefract Terrible! Disgusting, breach contracts, ignore calls. They were supposed to be managing a property for us. Totally ignored written instructions we gave for electrical work to be done twice over 2 years. There were other issues that needed resolving, the quotes were astronomical ! when we organised The tradesmen ourselves even though it was supposed to be fully managed. They were simple small jobs. A roofing job they quoted over £700 for was one tile that was cracked. An alleged damp issue in a brand-new kitchen they quoted over £4000 but turned out to be The neighbours bath that had sprung a leak and had gone down the wall. They then stated they had another landlord interested in the property we accepted the offer on the proviso it was a quick sale which 4 months Later still hasn’t gone through. They have a lettings negotiator dealing with the sale she is acting solely for the buyer even though they are charging for the sale.(Breach of contract) The buyer has a number of properties and they are trying to get the business at our expense. They used a nail n the floor as urgent work to be completed prior to the sale ! It had been sorted out weeks before ! A NAIL !!! I have explained my husband is seriously ill and asked them to push the sale through prior to any operations it took three weeks for Michelle Stobbard the manager to ring me back after insisting she took over personally! They are a disgrace avoid at all costs.Disgusting!

Lesley · 25 September 2020

★★★★★ 5/5

Trustpilot

Very good Service

Mike and Becky were great. They managed the letting and then sale of my father's property. Service was always very good, they were always responsive and willing to help and made the letting of the property hassle free.

Andrew · 3 July 2022

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

Frauders and scammers

Frauders and scammers. A company built on stolen money from honest people.Just got robbed half of my deposit because lies despite I have left the property in excellent conditions and got accused of damaging some furniture and received the flat dirty with already old broken furniture's.In fact I have provided myself dining table with chairs as the previous one was rotten.An unbelievable way to operate and an absence of service during the tenancy and after claiming to steal your money based on lies. Clearly a mafia built on internal politics to steal money to honest people. Avoid at all costs

Matteo · 24 December 2024

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

Was awful from start to finish

Was awful from start to finish. We should have realised that they were bad as we struggled to get through to them to make the appointment to view the property. Of course we got there fell in love with the view and said we would take it for a year. After packing up all our things in Essex they couldn't even tell us the exact date to move in because Freddy Jacques was so awful. Let me remind you we were moving from Essex not exactly round the corner from Sheffield. Well within the first week we had a couple of issues. I wanted to know who I had to pay the next lot of rent to the woman on the phone wouldn't give me the information and took multiple attempts to get this. They clearly didn't want paying. After having issues with both the hot water timer and the heating timer which was both badly handled. They couldn't tell me when the contractor was coming, who it was and when we did finally have someone and taking days off of work with him to fail to turn up three months later we got this fixed. We had heating but no way of controlling it in December and January. We handed in our 1 months notice and moved out earlier this year in June. When they carried out the final checks on the property, the report said and I quote "Requires a light clean" with the currant situation of Covid 19 I would of expected as a new tenant that the property would need a clean anyway which BTW doesn't happen before as we asked for it to be clean and it never materialised. I have read lots of reviews since moving out that say that they wanted money from you because of the state that you have left the property in and we were no different. They wanted £120 for a light clean... It was in better condition then when we moved in. Couple of pieces of advise to someone renting from Martin and Co is don't you will have so many issues and they say they will represent you but they don't. My second piece of advise is if they want money from you hold out we put our foot down and have got some of it back. We received £90 out of £120 I would say is a win.

Charlotte · 13 September 2020

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

Please read so you don't regret later!

Please read carefully if you are considering Martin & Co. as your letting agent.I started an agreement with them in November 2025 for a flat that was going to be vacant in December, after I passed all the reference processes, a contract was made after I paid the holding deposit, but I was unable to view the property as it was occupied (and they probably had issues with the tenant, so there was only a video tour provided).Almost a month after, and a week before getting the keys the apartment was finally empty. When I went to visit I found a lot of issues, from cleanliness to faulty appliances, soiled carpet that needed replacement, and awful overall conditions of the painting, bathrooms, and furniture. I asked for a deal to get the place fixed, painted, and renewed, on my own, but, the landlord didn't accept it, and now, 2 days before getting the keys with everything packed they just canceled my offer and said they would return my holding deposit.They don't answer the phone, ignore e-mails, and never speak to you clearly and have no empathy at all, even though they knew I had given notice where I currently live and was going to be homeless in a week, and because of holidays break, it will be nearly impossible to find another place in a suitable time.

Denis · 19 December 2024

★★★★★ 5/5

Trustpilot

Great to deal with

Great to deal with, very smooth process throughout the sale of my property, kept me updated along the way. Would deal with again

Andrew · 1 July 2026

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

Avoid at all costs.

Awful firm to deal with, left a very sour taste in the mouth when tenancy came to an end. Pleasant enough to deal with in the most part, until it comes to check-out time, when the focus turns to ripping you off and ensuring no tenant ever receives their full deposit back. In trying to mediate and sort an agreement out, they decided to submit deductions to the DPS without consent and never contacted me again, ignoring subsequent emails. Spineless. Anyone renting through this firm - take as many photos as possible as soon as you move in to evidence even the slightest whiff of dust or any slight blemish in the place, trust me, they will charge you for it at the end if you don't.. I would avoid at all costs if you can, I will certainly be recommending they are avoided to anyone I know myself.

Jacob · 26 January 2023

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

Keep all the evidence you can!

Do not use this company. The whole tenancy was nothing but a nightmare. The property was given to us in a terrible state. Dirty, grimy, mouldy and mostly everything given broken and not useable. We have just had the long process with the DPS of getting over £1000 deposit back, which they falsely took from us. We have just been awarded this under investigation showing them making up complete lies to make monetary gain. The people who work for this company are rude and nasty. I have seen running comments of this company taking deposits back from people, keeping peoples hard working money. Please I advise anyone with this issue to take as many photos and evidence that you can. This has helped us massively to catch them out and, reading comments this is something they think they can get away with. Do not trust these people.

Nola · 17 January 2023

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

Money grabbers!!

Not going to leave a lengthy review as it seems the others here have covered the same points. Nothing but fees, fees and fees. Luckily didn't have any problems during my tenancy but when moving out half the deposit was taken to have the property professionally cleaned. You would have thought due to the current climate some consideration would have been taken but obviously not. Do not hire a rug doctor to clean the carpets as apparently this does not count as professionally cleaned! May as well not clean the place as you will just be charged regardless... Whoever has been paid to clean the place has had the easiest money they will ever earn!! Glad I now own my own property and don't have to deal with these money grabbers, if I ever need to rent again I will not be touching this lot with a barge pole!!

Matt · 15 May 2020

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

Chocolate Teapot and Co

Avoid like covid19! If I could give any less stars I would. The whole thing has been an absolute joke. The could not organise a booze up in a brewery. From start to now and I'm only in 3 months into tenancy. If you saw this in a comedy sketch then you'd accept it! Start- they push you, put pressure on you to put money down deposit and to save the property. They Pester you. Constant emails about getting you to pay and giving you unrealistic deadlines. Likes it life or death. Once you're in they will mess you about on when to collect your keys to your new letting. They told me to be there at 330. So left work early to then be told the keys would not be ready until half 4. So I had the delight to sit in that dingy office for half an hour with the not so pleasant estate agents. I know its not a hotel, restaurant or pub but Jesus wept, be hospitable. You're tenants are spending a lot of money per month. Now you're in the property and you should need anything you may aswell do it yourself. When we moved in there was a faulty chair that I fell through and we still have not had a reply from that. That was almost 9 weeks ago. Trying to communicate with the staff is like all hope is gone. My flatmate has had to leave the property due to the pandemic and work related issues this was 5 weeks ago and we still haven't had a reply. This is a serious matter. We need her off the tenancy. We've been through things about 5 times with different staff. There is no communication between staff members. God forbid you dont have to find another job and have to interview because you'd seriously struggle. If you cannot be arsed helping us. Just tell us. We will contact the landlord. We will do things and probably make his life easier. I know there's a pandemic going on but maybe put an auto reply on and suggest that you're not going to be replying quickly our property manager - a chocolate tea pot is more useful.Reply to our emails and help us sort our lives out. I'm sure you dont want to keep seeing myself and my friends emaisl in your inbox 3 times a day looking for answers. By the look of things I'm not the only one who's having issues. So maybe the owners of the Martin and co chain really need to look into sorting this office out. It looks like people have become too comfortable in their jobs and don't want to make a difference anymore. Please get in touch with us. We need to move on. Weve got lives to live.

Luke · 15 May 2020

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

If you are looking to rent through a…

If you are looking to rent through a property through Martin and co, one word of advice - don’t. I’m a relatively easy going person and if I don’t have a great experience with a company 9 out of 10 times I let it go and move on with my day but honestly, the experience I had is beyond belief. I rented a property with my friend, firstly the fees to actually make an application were crazy. There’s an application fee, a credit check fee, a fee for referencing.. you name it there’s a fee for it -but whatever, we like the flat so paid. Make sure you have a couple of grand handy just to get your hands of the keys (which for most people like myself isn’t easy) being shown around the property we were told there wasn’t a washing machine but would be at the time of moving in. when we moved into the property there was mould all over the bathroom and kitchen - we cleaned it and didn’t complain. First day we went to put a load of washing on and realised the washing machine was a dud, not working, not attached to any of the plugs and when we pulled it out looked like they’d picked it up as scrap at the tip and shoved it in the kitchen to fill the gap - it didn’t turn on! We asked for a new one and was told they would sort it. This took 3 weeks after constant chasing up we both work on a hospital and need clean clothes for work. Next - expect constant inspections. Every month without fail, and you have no control over the time or date. I advised I was working nights so I would be asleep in the day but they insisted they couldn’t be flexible so I had to either stay awake (after staying awake all night) or they would barge in my bedroom whilst I was sleeping (this actually happened) Another ridiculous problem - our property had electric gates to the car park which they supplied us ONE key for between two adults; working different shifts. This meant if one of us had to go to work, the other would be trapped in the car park with no way out. Most days I would have to hang around in the car park an hour before work trying to catch someone else on their way in or out so I could leave! I informed them of this and their advice was ‘you’ll have to go round and knock on neighbours doors until someone can go and let you out’ OF MY OWN PROPERTY. I asked them for another key, they said they had another one but this was an office copy for their use only to conduct inspections. So basically, they were allowed access to and from my property more than myself who actually lived there. In the end they told me I had to buy another key fob out of my own money (80 quid) travel 20 miles to pick it up from another office. I did this out of desperation and they said they would refund this. That took 3 months of chasing up. Boiler was on the blink constantly and a month before I moved out it started pissing out water. Now with no hot water and no heating in January I rang them and they informed me they would have someone out as soon as possible. I chased this up for 2 weeks. It was so cold my flat mate moved back to her parents for this time. I was unable to so I was working all night, staying up all day ringing Martin and co with no luck or update. I had to stay awake because on the off chance a plumber turned up, I would have to go down to the car park and let the plumber in because of the gate situation! They also would not give us access to our meter readings and made us set up a fixed sum to pay the gas directly to them every month, after we insisted we check the meters it turned out our usage was a lot lower than what they were charging us and meant we were hundreds of pounds in credit! If we hadn’t said anything they would have kept taking our money and never said a word! The gate had an access code on it, I asked for this and they told me this was confidential despite me actually living there! I asked for money off the rent because it had made flat uninhabitable - I got a no. They also periodically increase the rent by small amounts and charge a hefty fee to renew your contract every 3-6 months. The part that really takes the biscuit is on moving out, I knew they would be a stickler for giving back the deposit. We repainted every room and professionally cleaned the carpets - then got a bill for the walls as we had repainted them THE WRONG SHADE OF WHITE! They also refused to give me my mail that had been delivered to the property afterwards. Advised they could not verify that I was the actual recipient of the mail, even after renting to me for two years. They actually had the mail behind the desk with me at the front of the desk and refused to give me it and advised I should contact Royal Mail and pay them to redirect all my mail. This was a letter from the nhs detailing an appointment I had been waiting for for 9 months so I then missed this and got put back on a waiting list. Oh and last but not least - the day we gave our notice in they started doing viewings on the flat that they expected US to host between shifts! Crazy!

Customer · 25 April 2020

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

Fees fees FEES!

Just finished my tenancy with these guys and I have to say I've not really been impressed throughout the 2 year tenancy. When we started the tenancy they presented us with a 30 page contract (yes. 30 pages.) and the agent was then dismayed and irritated when I insisted on reading every page before initialling and signing it (as you would - seeing as my previous contracts have been as short as 4 pages of A4). This was because they wanted to get out on time at 4pm on a Friday - You'd think being paid the fat end of £2.5k would warrant an extra 15 to 30 minutes in the office right? Right from the start of tenancy we had issues with the garage door opener which didn't work and it took them nearly 7 months to get us a replacement remote which actually worked. This was despite us chasing them weekly and even contacting the manufacturer ourselves to get the right spec - this definitely is above and beyond what I as the tenant should be doing.During the tenancy they wanted to conduct regular inspections - I have no issue with this but they were VERY uncooperative on when these inspections happened. Me and my housemate are both NHS healthcare professionals working shifts and they point blank refused to accommodate our shift pattern into their inspections because "they are very busy" and at one point even woke me up between nightshifts at 11am just to peak into my bathroom. (She was also surprised by me when I woke up with a start meaning that it clearly wasn't communicated to her that would be post-nights/sleeping either!)Around midway through the tenancy we encountered an issue with our utility supplier because we had been giving them readings from the wrong meter - when we asked M&Co where our electricity meter actually was, they wanted an £80 call-out fee to come and show us, even though the meter we had been taking readings from was the one they stipulated on their inventory documents. Thanks to assistance from other residence in the building, the actual meter was discovered behind a locked door which I was not provided a key for - in the end I had to go get one cut (oh and they refused to reimburse me for this too).This brings me on to the final issue with M&Co. FEES. Every single little thing has a fee attached to it and frankly, I've never known anything like it and I've rented a couple of times in different places around the county. So lets run though it: Set up fee: £225. Additional tenant fee: £75. Tenancy renewal fee: £75. Checkout fee: £120. Oh and call out fee: £80. (others that I thankfully managed to avoid paying include Guarantor Fee: £90, Amendment fee: £450 and out of hours service: £60). So for two people staying 2 years is a minimum of £495 in fees alone which I found to be unacceptable. (Oh and all of these are in addition to whatever they are charging the landlord - so good luck to the landlord here..)Another small niggle is that they are very sluggish to reply to emails which when they do reply, include lack of basic grammar and email etiquette. Written communications sometimes included one line and even one word replies - frankly its unprofessional. Your tenants are just as much your customers as your landlords are. Show some care and respect! I will given them that beyond the above, our tenancy ran smoothly and the property was lovely - but frankly I can't give them more than 1 star for this because these are the basics! There was no effort made on their part to improve the service they gave and frankly, when you're paying just short of £500 for something, I want it gold standard - this isn't. Sorry guys - You did ask for a review!

Tom · 23 April 2020

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

had issues with the place i live and…

had issues with the place i live and have submitted so many maintinence requests and they have sorted 0 of themEdit: no because you won't be able to do anything to help, i have gone to great lengths even contacting council to get issues sorted and still nothing has been done. I'm not wasting another minute talking to martin & co if i don't have to.update to this: sine i done this review i was without heating for 7 weeks so thanks again martin and co, i have since moved out and hope to never rent from martin and co again

Peter · 3 January 2023

★★★★★ 5/5

Trustpilot

Fantastic team

Fantastic team, they helped me în any issue,from start to finish, I want to thank to Michael and Kim , I felt safe to have them as a letting agency, very prompt and professionals. Thank you

Carmen · 29 July 2022

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

DO NOT USE

DO NOT USE. We went through Matthew Knight, we viewed a property on the Sunday out a deposit down and signed Terms of business on the Monday and got an email from him on Wednesday saying he was returning our deposit due to use not committing. After calling to discuss further this was due to me not wanting to hand my notice in on my current property until I had a signed contract. He tried to force us to continue to do so. They wanted us in by Jan 31st I asked if it was possible to have everything done with the Xmas period etc they said no. I asked if they have made the landlord aware that the move in date might change and then according to Matthew the landlord said they wouldn’t wait and the property would of been empty too long even though it would of only been available from Jan 9th. Turns out they had someone in the background that they wanted in the property rather than the landlord. Utterly disgusting way to treat people especially when a young family is involved.

Katie · 23 December 2022

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

USE WITH CAUTION

What a rubbish company. Rented with them for 3 years. Then no assistants to find alternative accom lived in black mould in 2 bedrooms lounge and dining room for the 3 years and did not sort. Things were so bad with the lack of care we got environmental health involved that imposed a survey ect. Inspection every 6 months. New manager in gosport Was worse as staff kept going sick and leaving. And did not care about his tenants. We are with a different company now and completely different and more trusting. We will never use this company again. On checkout we had receipts proving contract requirements were adhered to. Was taken to the tribunal and we won. THEY DON'T CARE they are so bad even the landlord sold the house with a different company.......

Graeme · 29 February 2020

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

look into this $hit house before…

Please look into this $hit house before you rent from them. As you can see by the majority of bad reviews, they’re useless! They rent out properties full of mould and will ignore your emails and calls for months about it. They can lie all they want about not knowing about it too but you can literally see on the windowsills that they’ve painted over mold in the past, it literally shows under the paint in clear view! You’d think in the light of the story in regards to the poor young boy who sadly lost his life to mold issues they’d be running at every opportunity to sort out every mold and or damp issue, but they still don’t care. It doesn’t matter if you have children either they could not give a single $hit. I can’t even begin to list the amount of problems wrong with their property but it needs sorting and they need SHUTTING DOWN FOR GOOD. Ive taken photographic proof of everything and will be sending them over to the papers and the MP along with a long letter.

Kay · 15 December 2022

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

Its not your dream home if its with Martin and Co!

Martin and Co is the single worst estate agent I have ever know, I am begging you please do not use them. I rented a house with them for 9 months and it’s the worst experience I’ve ever had with an estate agents (I‘ve lives in 8 different rented houses before this one!!) despite asking ten separate times they refused to get me any access to contact my own land lord and they even told me he would visit one day and never turned up, I never once got to speak to him. I had unbelievable maintenance issues including but not limited to: lights with no fittings, a cellar that wasn’t sealed and caused a gale to blow through the whole house, damp like you wouldn’t believe, and a shower that leaked so aggressively it was causing damage to the infrastructure of the house, I emailed about all of these and they refused to fix them, I put in formal notice to their website that they needed fixing and they refused to acknowledge them. By the time I left the house wasn’t fit to live in and despite knowing this they moved someone new in within two weeks of me leaving. I also had issues that they kept calling me while I was at work despite repeatedly telling them not to. And is that the worst? Not by a long shot! The worst by far is one of the people who works there, a man by the name Lee who was the most disgustingly disrespectful person I have ever know, I don’t know how he ever got hired! Refusing to respond to emails, lying about maintenance (as if I wasn’t living in the house and knew what was wrong with it!), being rude and speaking down to me, hanging up the phone! The whole shebang! And now, after another staff member doing an inspection of the property upon me leaving it and agreeing it was completely fine, they’re trying to take nearly £200 of my deposit from me just for the sake of it. PLEASE, PLEASE SAVE YOURSELF AND DO NOT GO WITH MARTIN AND CO!!

Benjamin · 1 February 2020

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

Poor experience

We never had a single issue with this agency for three whole years. Regular property inspections were carried out every six months, we kept the house in good condition, paid rent on time without fail, and thoroughly cleaned the property the day before returning the keys.

Samantha · 16 December 2025

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

BUYER BEWARE

BUYER BEWARE! If you are looking to purchase a property with Martin & Co - Leamington and Warwick branchThe listing we viewed for a freehold property we were interested in was misleading and did not contain key information, information that had we had known prior to viewing would have resulted in looking elsewhere. We were mislead on key property details and key information regarding the involvement of a management company and service charges associated with the property...we had to pay a solicitor to find these things out ...all of which should have been included in the listing.There was no ownership of the misleading listing, it was always the fault of another party...which was interesting as the only "professional" involved was the agent.

Richard · 21 December 2019

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

Check contracts

I personally would not deal with Martin and Co again i'll briefly highlight the below ;- Have pets on application however Landlord was not informed - Breach contract - Will not come back to you when you have a complaint about service/contract breach unless you chase - Director is quite sassy (I won't lie I enjoyed this however pretty bad ethics if you don't enjoy this) - Didn't inform landlord of any changes- Blindly agree unless they have a problem- Force you into fixed term contracts for the first year.

Michael · 11 December 2019

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

AVOID AVOID AVOID this agency

AVOID AVOID AVOID this agency. it tooks 2 weeks trying to rent a room in sharehouse It s very difficult to reach them by email or phone. They changed 3 times the hour and the day of the appointement to view the room. I immediately booked this room as I had already lived there for 3 years. they did not wanted to rent it to me. they didn't want to do a virtual view like the previous nice landlord had done due to my disability. I have insisted a lot to have this room which had all the criteria for my disability. I did everything they resquested. I wasted a lot of time and money. After two weeks they said they have choosen someone else.I think the agency did not want to rent me the room because of my disability. they give a very bad image of English agencies. To avoid. Unprofessional, inhuman, bad customer service.

Aurélie · 20 November 2022

★★★★★ 1/5

Trustpilot

If I could give access minus I would

If I could give access minus I would! Totally unprofessional letting agents even the lettings negotiator Sara is useless. Turned up for a viewing that had taken 3 weeks to organise as the estate agents blamed the current tenants were not letting prospective tenants view the property. We were made to queue up like a bus queue outside in drizzly rain to view the property. We arrived on time and waited 15 mins then left as no co-ordination in viewing and no sign of even Sara the lettings negotiator who was clearly there as we saw her little company car. Going on previous reviews it looks like we may have had a lucky escape! M

Mrs · 12 October 2019