Trusted Agent profile · Sheffield

Martin & Co Sheffield reviews

2.0

★★★★★

859 reviews across 3 platforms

51 Middlewood Road, Sheffield, S6 4GW, S6 4GW

Part of Martin & Co, see every office.

Martin & Co's office in Sheffield, at 51 Middlewood Road, is rated 2.0 out of 5 across 859 reviews on three platforms.

Facebook logo

2.6 / 5

5

Reviews on Facebook

This office

Yell logo

1.0 / 5

2

Reviews on Yell

This office

Trustpilot logo

852

Reviews on Trustpilot

Business-wide

Reviews may appear on more than one platform.

Reviews

Every review we hold for the Sheffield office, from every platform, shown as written. First names only.

5/5

Trustpilot

agents martin and co friendly and well…

agents martin and co friendly and well organized , also fair house pricing and advised all way through selling process , would recommend to anyone for a smooth transaction in to days market

Japenny · 23 July 2026

1/5

Trustpilot

I would not recommend this company to…

I would not recommend this company to anyone trying to rent , I was second to view a property in Warminster then just called again to be told there is no longer any viewings. This has happened a number of times with this company!!!!!

Ms · 30 April 2026

1/5

Trustpilot

Left waiting outside.

Let me turn up for a viewing. Lied saying they were on their way., Then lied to say it was cancelled and I was notified. Couldn’t prove I was notified or that they even tried. Do not waste your time.

RDB · 12 May 2026

1/5

Trustpilot

Use the local office to let out my…

Use the local office to let out my property. The rent has been late on several occasions, I have to chase the Tennant myself, there is zero communication or work being done on their part. The local office is never open and looks abandoned, no one ever answers any of the phone numbers I have. The property has now been up for sale for a few months and I have not once heard from them. If ypu phone the line to 'book a viewing at a property' it rings and rings until it cuts off. There is literally no one to speak to. Worst company I have ever had the displeasure of dealing with. AVOID AVOID AVOID

Oliver · 27 May 2022

1/5

Trustpilot

Martin & Co - Guarantor issue

My partner and I were through the whole process of renting a flat. Papers were signed at beginning, all information was given when asked. We were told that we'd got the place, and just needed a guarantor - moved back from Australia so they needed extra reassurance, which was fine. The guarantor gave all information needed. Even employer contact information so they could validate. We were set to move in on the 18th May, the day before we had been told we lost the flat as they didn't get a copy of the guarantor's contract of employment. It is no business of theirs to need that, everything else had been shown and was evident that he could pay if needed. We lost the holding fee of 300 pounds, and were given no other option. After trying for hours to get hold of them, none of the calls were getting through, we had to leave it and try to find somewhere to stay.We had to move out our current rental, and had nowhere to go.DO NOT USE THIS AGENT

Corinne · 19 May 2022

1/5

Trustpilot

Unreliable agent

Unreliable & Unprofessional agent everSince before our booking appointment to view this house, we clearly mentioned that we, 4 people, will share the house. We did a tenancy application form, mentioning 4 people will share and then wired holding fees.The Agent was doing reference & bank checking for all of us and got a reply that they have all passed.So, we already confirmed with our current landlord for moving date and also arranged to remove the household, book for moving agencies & deep cleaning service to this current house.1 week before our moving date, Martin & Co sent us a mail that '' I am ever so sorry but we cannot continue with the application because landlord wasn’t aware a license was required for sharers which he doesn’t hold”. I am really surprised that they did all reference check, bank check to all of us without realising the landlord has that license. Can you all imagine how much difficult for us to find a new house within a week? I just want to share my experience to everyone how unreliable this agent is.

K · 14 May 2022

5/5

Trustpilot

I’m very grateful to Tonia Pool for her…

I’m very grateful to Tonia Pool for her prompt and efficient help in resolving the heating and hot water issue. She was very attentive to my problem and quickly arranged for the appropriate specialist to come and fix it. Best wishes, Tetiana Teslya

Tetiana · 10 April 2026

5/5

Trustpilot

Incredible Customer Service

We purchased a property from Martin & Co. and had a really great experience. They have deep understanding of the market and were super helpful with the buying process. Special thanks to Steven from Martin & Co. for the exceptional service and was incredibly responsive to our queries. He was professional, helpful, and quick to respond.I would highly recommend Martin & Co. for anyone looking for a new property.

Avinash · 26 May 2023

5/5

Trustpilot

Fantastic experience buying a property

WeHave just had a fantastic experience buying a property through Martin and CoSue Wright was friendly professionallyAnd so accommodatingCommunication was excellent and support was there from viewing the property to our completion dateI can’t thank Sue and her team enoughAndI would definitelyRecommend them to anyone in the future

Angela · 20 August 2024

1/5

Trustpilot

SLUM LANDLORDS

SLUM LANDLORDS - My partner & I rented a property through this company. My partner lived in the property for 7 years and I lived there 2 years. In April 2021 we reported damp in the bedroom coming from the old boiler. They did nothing. In October we found mushrooms growing behind our bed along with a large patch of mould. I contacted them and threatened to take the to tribunal if they didn't fix the issue. It was fixed in 3 days at that point. Then came our six months notice to leave. We were told not to rush but the company harassed us into leaving. We eventually moved out after three months and have now been advised we have to pay for multiple services. They have claimed that the oven needs cleaning, yet in their original documentation regarding the state of the property it is noted that the oven is in a poor state. They have claimed we broke a window yet as the property has not been maintained within the seven years rental the old wooden frames have rotted away. This has been reported to them on several occasions via the telephone and via email yet now they are trying to charge us for it. There was one instance where, for whatever reason, my partner paid the rent a handful of days later than usual yet this didn't stop one of their employees sending a vile and billious email threatening eviction for being late with the money. Not one seconds thought or consideration to there being a global pandemic and the possibility my partner, as a key worker, may have been ill with the virus. When challenged it was apparently an automated message, which if true, I would suggest someone with better grammar and ability at writing puts together all automated communications. In short, if you are looking to rent, avoid this business.

Ian · 14 January 2022

5/5

Trustpilot

Fantastic!!!

This review is well overdue. I am so thankful to Cindie Shirley who dealt with my house purchase ( Rainham Kent ). She is efficient, courteous, well informed and approachable. Great customer service. There was no need for me to speak to members of her team due to her professionalism. She liaised effortlessly with solicitors, vendors etc. The entire process was flawless and stress free for me. Cindie is hardworking and I will recommend her over and over again. She is a great asset to the company. Cindie you are just fantastic!!!

Christine · 31 October 2021

2/5

Trustpilot

Gangster

Hi,After viewing a property twice with an Agent and with the owner and after putting forward an offer .The process of providing all documents and the initiation of the Mortgage were ongoing , I found out that the Agent not the Owner had made the decision without contacting us (during the 7 days that passed) to sell it to another buyer at the same price?I have never come across this kind of a sales man concept. Never again Martin&Co .

Nadia · 29 September 2021

1/5

Trustpilot

Would give 0 or negative rating but…

Would give 0 or negative rating but unfortunately 1 is the lowest I can give. The flat was given to us without any in person viewing ( I had to accept it because I was relocating from another city). It was dirty and seems like they put little effort in cleaning the flat before handing over.

Navadeep · 12 November 2025

1/5

Trustpilot

Greedy,layer,cheater company ever I had experience over 11 years in the UK.

My experience from the Martin and co especially one of the staff Becky.Absolutely arrogant, layer into your face and speak with you unacceptable. House that I left were absolutely clean I have 124 images from it in and out including the oven. We agreed £50 deduction (which was not reasonable deduction anyway. I showed to my lovely neighbours to get their advices) They explained the deduction for the owen clean....I thought lets be happy everyone take it then .After I moved to overseas it's raised up to £150 .They are extremely greedy unreliable company .Here is the email that is shows the all short story to copied here.IGNORE MARTIN AND CO!!!!To Becky../Martin and CoActually we both new that would not be straight forward as we know your office and landlord's attitude. But let me take some Indication too. We lived in the property 7.5 years that the rent has never ever been late or whatsoever. When my son was 2 years old (just like the landlord son) we have left in the property with wrong boiler no hot water and heting that was uncomfortable in January with the baby for over two years despite of the regular reports. This was disgusting and I presume illegal too from side of landlord.At the very first agreement included the wrong appliances will be replaced that never been happened so we bought new dishwasher,new washing machine,also we fitted a water purifier which is cost £800 only this all left in the property.total cost circa £1600 we never moaned for it.Moreover throughout 7.5 years of period we paid at least £54000 anIs it absolutely outrageous that these minor issues the reason that you would like to deduct our deposit. We showed all fairness, maintained, decorated the property every single year.I showed all neighbourhood's the property and all of them said that wouldn't be any problem at all.We all loved by our lovely neighbours that they were said will help us to take this case further if necessary. The stuff in the garde will be cleared out one of the neighbour tomorrow morning. Also I taken pictures very detailed that you required that isn't rich the standard of your office in case of the further steps . Please note I do not stay for a long back in Hungary .If any deduction will applied against our deposit I will definitely go further .It is absolutely unacceptable, outrageous, disgusting. By the way I wundering how others leave the property after .Kind Regards Roland

Horvath · 30 July 2021

5/5

Trustpilot

Excellent and Professional

Kerri was fantastic on my first viewing and arranged a second viewing really quickly when requested. Kerri was very professional throughout.

Stacey · 20 June 2025

1/5

Trustpilot

Intrusive and Tone-Deaf Marketing

I’ve had unsolicited flyers from this estate agent put through our letterboxes, even though there’s a clear “no junk mail” notice for the building. What’s more, they’ve somehow got into the block and delivered them inside, ignoring that notice completely.

Matthew · 17 March 2026

5/5

Trustpilot

Five Stars. Great service.

I have found Martin & Co of excellent service. Janice at Martin & Co in Woolton was excellent at helping me to buy my perfect home a while back. She kept me up to date and the house sale was completed in good time and therefore I decided to contact Martin & Co (Who have now moved to Allerton Road) when I needed new tenants for an apartment that I own. Once again, they delivered a great service. The new tenants had moved in a week after the previous had left. Additionally, the tenants seem really nice so I'm really pleased and I don't have to worry about my property being empty and where I will find the money to cover the rent. I will definitely be using Martin & Co in the future, the team on Allerton Road are really friendly and helpful. Thankyou so much.

Vanessa · 3 March 2021

1/5

Trustpilot

During the tenancy everything was well…

During the tenancy everything was well occasionally when the landlord did not want to carry out works this was communicated clearly but we had some issues towards the end of tenancy when the landlord wanted to claim money off our deposit for issues that was already there when we moved in. They had lot the evidence of check in document and then sided with the landlord instead of even trying to understand our side and were very rude. In the end when the claim when to dispute with deposit scheme we managed to find our copy of the check in which proved that the issues were there in the first place and our deposit refunded. There was no acknowledgement or support as a tenant from the agency and infact they were very rude about it.

Liam · 2 March 2021

1/5

Trustpilot

If you want to feel like your always last on the list, this is the agency for you!

To this day I wonder why me and my partner chose them. I'm sure I will wonder till I die. As a landlord, this is the agency for you! They will go far and wide, by breaching contracts, just to protect your interest! That's right! They will do criminal things and get their ass on the line just to get you an extra £ or two! I was just charged 70£ for cleaning, when I left it in x5 better than it's original condition! Oh, wait. The landlord doesn't actually get this money. So I guess, even for landlords, this is not the agency for you! You might get held up with a small claims court for no reason whatsoever! By contract I was supposed to get the deposit within 8 days after giving in the keys. Today the ''issue'' is resolved, which would make it the 23rd day. Almost x3, a day short, damn, so close. This delay was not on ''my part'' or the ''landlords part''. It was simply the agents failing to contact either of us. They do not care, they will not care. The maintenance teams they use are bloody ridiculous. If I have to go into details about that, your head will spin.If you're a masochist, like to be ignored, enjoy getting your nerves stretched for stupid little things and like spending more than you should, choose them. There was only 1 decent person there, Andy Swallow, felt I should mention it. Even for him I can't lift up my star rating, sorry Andy, your a nice guy. Consider moving.

Not · 23 February 2021

5/5

Trustpilot

PLUMBER CHRIS....SHEFFIELD 50 STARS

PLUMBER CHRIS.....He sorted a problem we had with hot water, a few days ago. The boiler stopped working yesterday (Saturday), so no heating or hot water. His number is for out of hours emergency, so I called and left a message as well as text message, just so it would already be reported ready for when he could come to do it. He text me today (Sunday) saying he would call in to have a look. Great!! As it turns out it was a quick fix. The thing is, it's his day off, he was at home with the little one, his missus came home from work for an hour as usual, then he rushed here.CHRIS WENT ABOVE AND BEYOND to sort a job that he could have left until tomorrow. Thank you Chris, 50 stars.

Kay · 26 January 2021

1/5

Trustpilot

Incompetent in all areas

We rented a property for over a year, we always paid rent on time and looked after the property but to say that Martin and Co martinco.com are a borderline scam and extremely incompetent is an understatement to say the least. First of all, the rent was high so I assume the landlord paid a fairly hefty fee for Martin and Co to look after the property (though I don't know that for a fact) so what they actually do with this fee is beyond me.Lets start from the beginning...INCOMPETENCE:That is the general word I would use for this company, in particularly from the lady who managed our property Barbara Cousins. Where do I begin, first of all she doesn't even know how to use basic email, for instance as we lived in the shared property we BOTH needed to be cc'd and replied to with communications, I must have explained this 10 times via email but she still continued to constantly fail at this basic task, meaning me and the missus where constantly going back and forth catching up and forwarding things to make actual sense. Then, just having general conversations about logical things regarding the property seemed to confuse her, this isn't a character assassination but I honestly don't know how she got the job, unless she's a family member, friend or something similar within the company as it certainly isn't on skill set I can tell you that. My girlfriend, who is known for her patience just couldn't deal with her anymore. The worst one was (and you wont believe this) our ceiling fell through due to a dodgy waste pipe and was flooding the house, we rang them immediately and explained, Barbara said and I quote "not sure if we can get someone out right now, but just don't have a bath" - yes, she actually said that, says it all really.Now on to the building work (if you can call it that). They seem to hire a man called Michael, I assume he is cheap because Martin and Co clearly don't like spending money and have made that clear on several occasions. He is a "I can do any job" type of bloke, he comes across as a cowboy in the work he does, which is exceptionally low quality, in fact, I, in my limited DIY skill set often had to give him advise - even the missus had to show him how to locate the stop tap for the water and how to use it which was hilarious. SCAMFirst of all, we initially signed for 6 months, but in the contract they tried to put 12 months on there until we noticed, they of course apologized and amended it but, an honest mistake or an attempt to try and increase the contract? you decide. Constantly trying to save money, multiple occasions I was called by the to try and work my work schedule around builders so "they could save money"...yes, they actually said that. When we left the property, aside from the broken ceiling (which was not our fault) the house was actually in cleaner and better condition than when we moved in, and, there was a few crumbs in the oven and got charged over £200 for them to clean it! also, some light bulbs went due to the bad wiring (and reoccurring issue) and got charged £5/new light despite not being our fault. Lastly, deposit. We was told several times that they requested the deposit release from the DPS, yet never received it. After several weeks we had to manually call them and force it to be released as the agents never actually contacted the deposit protection scheme. Generally an absolute mess, these people need investigating.

Foxy · 14 December 2020

4/5

Trustpilot

Ignore tenant smears

I’ve worked with many Martin & CO’s and they’re really good despite the tenant venting seen on this site. Ignore tenants moaning. It’s fashionable to weaponise negative reviews against businesses these days. Rents increase, tenants leave properties dirty. Get over it.

David · 22 February 2026

5/5

Trustpilot

I had a lovely experience with the…

I had a lovely experience with the Staines branch moving into my new flat.Everything was handled by Jolene who was incredibly professional and easy to talk to. She sorted everything out for me and was incredibly quick to respond to any questions I had. At all points she was very clear with the information she needed from me and was able to explain the process clearly.When it came moving day, we were actually running rather late, but Jolene was on hand to help and calm us down. She was kind enough to adjust her schedule substantially and meet us at the property to hand over the keys. I am incredibly grateful for all her help as she took all the stress out of moving at every stage.Wishing her all the best. She is a credit to the company.

JFranklin · 29 November 2020

1/5

Trustpilot

The worst company I have ever dealt with AVOID

The worst company I have ever dealt with. Rented with them for 1 year. During that time, there was a leak in the property and when the plumber came out and confirmed it was due to poor work on the bath seal previously. The leak resulted in the carpet being sodden in the bedroom. The smell was horrendous which made the property unhabitable. After 1 week and numerous emails, Martin & Co finally sent someone out to have a look at the damage. They deemed it to be fine to live in. Having spent 2 weeks in a hotel, I emailed to see about getting any money knocked off the rent/compensation towards hotel costs. This was denied. This happened one month before the end of my tenancy. I was then sent a letter asking me to vacate the premises on my tenancy end date which I did think was normal. When I asked if it would be possible to extend for one month(due to the start date on a potential new property) I was informed they had a new tenant already. I then saw a property advertised with Martin & Co which I applied for. I explained to the lady in the office that I had adverse credit but she said this would be ok to apply as I had declared it. I paid the holding deposit for £196.00 and sent off the application. I was then told that due to the adverse credit, and being asked to vacate the previous property, my application has failed and they would be keeping the holding deposit. I emailed their office and explained that I had not been asked to leave, my tenancy had simply ended. I also forwarded the email from the lady in the office where I asked about the credit situation. I then received a reply saying the lady in the office was new and that she didn't understand the process fully. I am STILL waiting for my holding deposit to be returned so this is now in the process of being taken further. I am writing this review to hopefully warn off others from using this company as they only seem to care about money. As you can see from the other reviews, many agree

May · 7 March 2023

Agent replied · 24 October 2024

Hello May, we are sorry to learn that you were not satisfied with the service provided by a Martin & Co office. To help us further our investigation, would you please email us your contact information and the name of the branch?Email: social.media@martinco.com

Where the same review appears twice we show it once. We leave out reviews that name another agent or another of the brand's offices.

The Trusted Agent

Is this your office? Claim your page.