Trusted Agent profile · Selby

Hunters Selby reviews

3.1

★★★★★

889 reviews across 2 platforms

23 Finkle Street, Selby, YO8 4DT, YO8 4DT

Hunters's office in Selby, at 23 Finkle Street, is rated 3.1 out of 5 across 889 reviews on two platforms, including 277 Google reviews rated 4.9.

Google logo

4.9 / 5

277

Reviews on Google

This office

Trustpilot logo

612

Reviews on Trustpilot

Business-wide

Want a trusted local agent to help?

Tell us what you need and we'll put you in touch. Hunters Selby hasn't joined The Trusted Agent yet, so we'll pass your enquiry to them or to up to three other top-rated agents near Selby.

What do you need help with?

Awards

ESTAS

Industry awards

Hunters Selby won ESTAS awards in two years, most recently 2023.

ESTAS winner in two years: 2023, 2022.

ESTAS awards by year, 2023 to 2022

Source: ESTAS winners lists, as published, linked by year.

Reviews

Every review we hold for the Selby office, from every platform, shown as written. First names only.

5/5

Google

We had a great experience purchasing a property through Hunters. The staff were all super helpful and friendly. Communications were great throughout the viewing and purchasing process. Would thoroughly recommend using Hunters both for Buying and Selling

Steve · 10 May 2026

Agent replied · 10 October 2026

Dear Steve, thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

Best Estate Agent I have ever used by far. James and Lisa were unbelievably friendly and helpful, we managed to go from viewing, to completion in 4 weeks! We were kept in the loop and updated every step of the way which really gave us a lot of confidence in the Hunters Selby team.

Charlie · 17 December 2025

Agent replied · 22 December 2025

Dear Charlie - thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

Hunters estate agents in Selby provided a fantastic service. Both James and Lisa were there every step of the way providing updates and communicating during all stages of the process. They really went above and beyond and nothing was too much trouble. If I am ever to move in the future I would 100% use hunters and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend to family and friends.

Sara · 18 August 2025

Agent replied · 8 September 2025

Dear Sarah - thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Trustpilot

Excellant service

Moving can be hectic, but Dulcie made it so simple with her support, prompt communication, and quick responses from the first viewing in Cullompton right through to the day I collected the keys. She was professional, reassuring, and always ready to help. The team I met on key‑collection day was amazing, friendly, welcoming, and incredibly helpful. Overall, a fantastic experience. Highly recommended.

Barbara · 1 June 2026

5/5

Google

We had great service from James Lisa and Chelsea right from the best quote through to a very stressful move. Thank you James for dealing with all the issues calmly and professionally and always there to help. We definitely recommend the Selby team and have no hesitation in recommending to others for making moving as easy as possible.

Jon · 15 October 2025

Agent replied · 9 November 2025

Dear Jon - thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

1/5

Trustpilot

Rude, poor service - a must avoid for renters

Rude, get passed around from pillar to post while they try to ignore your requests or questions. Tried for years to get them to fix things but just continually fell on deaf ears. Now they're trying to claim issues are my fault which are down to shoddy contractors (which they use consistently, including at one point despite having had yearly gas checks, I get told that the previous 6 years hasn't been done properly and the build up that caused a leak was because of this. Everything is everyone's issue but theirs. Renters, avoid at all costs!

Dominic · 10 January 2026

5/5

Google

Hunters are a fantastic team. After personally working in the property industry for 18 years and dealing with estate agents day in day out - some are definitely more on it than others. From the minute our house went on the market with them they were brilliant. Constantly communicated with, always knew what was happening. My house sold within a week, unfortunately our buyer did pull out but hunters had it sold again within the hour. I couldn’t have asked for better service. We also completed extremely quickly and I put that solely down to how James chased things to keep everything together. Thank you so so much to the whole team - you are fab! X

Kylie-Ann · 10 May 2026

Agent replied · 10 October 2026

Dear Kylie-Ann, thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

I have recently sold my house through Hunters, and I can't reccomend them highly enough. They have been proactive without being pushy, and have kept me informed throughout the process. The whole sale was going really smoothly, until the seller of the property I am buying put a spanner in the works by trying to change the date. James talked through what to do with me and the situation was resolved quickly. Both Lisa and James have their finger on the pulse and both always knew what was going on so I never had to wait to speak to 'the right person' when I called, and I never felt I was being a nuisance by asking too many questions. A great team and a great agency has made selling a lot less stressful than I expected.

Janice · 10 May 2026

Agent replied · 10 October 2026

Dear Janice, thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

James at Hunters was absolutely outstanding throughout our house purchase. From start to finish, he worked incredibly hard, far more than anyone else in the chain, to keep everything moving and on track. It genuinely felt like he was the one holding things together at times, pushing for progress when things could easily have stalled. He kept us regularly updated, which made a huge difference during what can be a very stressful process. We always knew where things stood and what the next steps were, which gave us real confidence. Honestly, we don’t think we would be in our new home now if it wasn’t for James. His persistence, communication, and dedication really set him apart. We wouldn’t hesitate to recommend him to anyone buying or selling a property.

Annalise · 10 April 2026

Agent replied · 10 October 2026

Dear Annalise, thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

I recently sold my property using Hunters and I honestly can't recommend them highly enough. Its the first time I've ever sold a house and I didn't have a clue what I was doing but Chelsea, Lisa and James guided me through every single step, supporting me all the way. They sold my house quickly, they are professional and caring. These guys really are the best and I would definitely recommend them. Thanks so much for all you did for me.

Margaret · 10 April 2026

Agent replied · 10 October 2026

Dear Margaret, thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

Thank you James, Thank you Lisa. You've both been brilliant. Clear communication, prompt help. The team at Hunters supported us with the sale of our house in Selby.

Graham · 10 May 2026

Agent replied · 10 October 2026

Dear Graham, thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

Excellent service and having face to face contact is priceless. James and Lisa were so helpful in guiding us through what can be a stressful process, we wholeheartedly recommend Hunters Selby.

Sadie · 10 April 2026

Agent replied · 10 October 2026

Dear Sandra, thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

James was amazing from start to finish he made us feel welcome and comfortable when we first viewed the property as well as answering all our questions and helping us out through out the process. James also did a great job chasing stuff up with both solicitors and made the process quicker and smoother! Great work James thank you!

J · 17 July 2025

Agent replied · 8 October 2025

Good afternoon - thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

A very friendly and professional service all around. I was always kept in the loop when things got a little complicated. Lisa Duncan was incredibly patient and kind during a somewhat stressful time, anyone that engages with her should feel they are in a very safe pair of hands.

Simon · 10 October 2025

Agent replied · 10 October 2026

Dear Simon, thank you so much for your five star review, it was our pleasure, with very best wishes - Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

James and Lisa were super helpful and informative all the way through our sale/buying process. I would highly recommend Selby Hunters to anyone, I couldn't have asked for better agents. Thank you so much for easing the stress of moving house!

Maddie · 15 December 2025

Agent replied · 22 December 2025

Dear Maddie - thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

I have recently sold my property through Hunters in Selby. The experience was second to none, they were so supportive, kind and caring throughout the process and I will be recommending them to anyone who is looking to sell their property. I also have another property to sell and I will be only using Hunters in Selby to assist me in selling this. First class service and couldn't of asked for anything more. Thank you again to James, Lisa and Chelsea for selling my property so quickly, effectively and sensitively. I highly recommend this company.

Wendy · 10 February 2026

Agent replied · 10 October 2026

Dear Wendy - thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

James, Lisa and Chelsea offered a first class service. James was always first on the ball, always keeping us updated along the way and quick to address any problems in the chain that arose. Absolutely brilliant from start to finish and cant thanks the team enough. Thanks Guys!

Tom · 10 September 2025

Agent replied · 8 October 2025

Dear Tom - thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

Hunters were brilliant and couldn't do enough for me during my sale. Definitely go beyond what you would expect and their customer service was exceptional. Full follow up calls following viewings and took care of everything. Even turned off my heating when I was away! Negotiated a good price for my property and after sales service was fab. James, Lisa and his team are top notch and I would definitely recommend them as the best choice in the Selby area

Chris · 25 June 2024

Agent replied · 23 October 2024

Dear Chris - thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

I can't speak highly enough of the service that the team at hunters offered, they went above and beyond throughout the selling process. We had a bad experience with one of their competitors and moving across was the best thing we could have done. James kept in constant communication with the viewing feedback and quickly got the house sold. Lisa was then absolutely brilliant in negotiating the lower chain and getting the completion over the line, I don't know what we would have done without her! I would 100% recommend Hunters to anyone looking to put their house on the market.

Jordan · 26 May 2024

Agent replied · 9 November 2024

Dear Jordan - thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

Selling a house can be a really stressful experience but with James and Lisa looking after you nothing was too much trouble. On first meeting James we had a frank discussion about pricing and I trusted him from day one. I had weekly updates and didn’t have to chase for any information on viewings etc. Once sold James and Lisa liased with solicitors and the buyers. We were kept up to date every step of the way. I cannot recommend James and Lisa enough. A real professional team

Charlene · 26 April 2024

Agent replied · 9 November 2024

Dear Charlene - thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Google

Couldn't recommend Lisa and James enough. Even though my solicitors were a nightmare, Lisa kept everything in check and kept me thoroughly updated. They were both a pleasure to deal with, I'll be sure to use them in the future.

Hugh · 10 October 2025

Agent replied · 10 October 2026

Good evening, thank you so much for your five star review, it was our pleasure, with very best wishes - Hunters Selby Team

5/5

Trustpilot

Wish I could give more stars

Wish I could give more stars ! BIG thank you to John Duffy and the team for guiding me through such a difficult time. An all round professional and caring service from the start. John was always passionate, easy to contact, swift with replies and information and genuinely caring of my situation. Found the perfect couple for my house and also found me a new home. Would highly recommend. 🌟 🌟 🌟

Sally.littlehotmail.co.uk · 4 September 2025

5/5

Google

Fantastic service throughout! This is the second time I have used Hunters to sell a property. Always there to answer the phone when you need them, great communication throughout. Great at providing updates. Thank you again for helping me sell my property!

Jess · 10 September 2026

Agent replied · 23 October 2024

Dear Jess, thank you so much for your five star review, we really appreciate it, best wishes Hunters Selby Team

1/5

Trustpilot

Awful customer service

I remain deeply disappointed in the way my most recent complaint has been handled at their Newcastle branch. The way the branch manager speaks to tenants is appalling! If you have a complaint then don’t expect any sympathy or accountability. We have rented this property for 11 years and in that time, we have been superb tenants but sadly that doesn’t mean anything to them. I anticipate a reply to this which will more than likely attempt to completely contradict what I’ve written here but just know that our experience has not been a positive one!

Jennifer · 25 July 2026

Where the same review appears twice we show it once. We leave out reviews that name another agent or another of the brand's offices.

Read Hunters's Google reviewsLeave Hunters a review

Questions about Hunters Selby

Has Hunters won any awards?

Yes. Hunters Selby won Best in Postcode (YO8) at the ESTAS 2023 awards, its most recent, and ESTAS awards in one earlier year.

Want a trusted local agent to help?

Tell us what you need and we'll put you in touch. Hunters Selby hasn't joined The Trusted Agent yet, so we'll pass your enquiry to them or to up to three other top-rated agents near Selby.

What do you need help with?

Reviews may appear on more than one platform.

The Trusted Agent

Is this your office? Claim your page.

Get help from an agent