2/5
They barely reply to emails. You call to view and they won't let you know if the viewing has been arranged for you and then you find out the property has been sold in the meantime and nobody let you know. Yeah, no, go with another agency.
Trusted Agent profile
★★★★★
11 reviews across 1 platform
1 Drummond Street, Comrie PH6 2DW
Irving Geddes WS's Comrie office at 1 Drummond Street is rated 3.6 out of 5 across 11 reviews on 1 platform, including 11 Google reviews rated 3.6. Checked 9 October 2026.
Every review we hold for the Comrie office, from every platform, shown as written. First names only.
2/5
They barely reply to emails. You call to view and they won't let you know if the viewing has been arranged for you and then you find out the property has been sold in the meantime and nobody let you know. Yeah, no, go with another agency.
1/5
We were advised of what the client wanted for the house when our first offer was rejected. We spoke to our financial adviser about increasing our mortgage. Irving Geddes contacted us again and asked us a few days later to resubmit our initial offer so rather than putting in the higher offer that the seller wanted and our mortgage advisor had agreed to, we did as Irving Geddes asked and resubmitted our initial offer and entered into negotiation with them. There was no closing date set and we were not made aware of any other offers (which would be highly irregular anyway as agents should not be negotiating with more than one buyer at a time). We were willing to go up to this time to the amount the seller had wanted as we had spoken to our mortgage advisor but after requesting we put in our initial offer (that the seller had initially rejected) they just ignored our calls and our solicitor's calls for updates during the negotiation process. Absolutely awful experience. Lost out on several other homes due to the way they dealt with the situation and worried about where we will go when we have to leave pour own house just before Christmas. We have submitted a formal complaint regarding the whole scenario. Very bad communication and very strange practice going on here.
1/5
Not recommended! Awkward and very old-fashioned in its views. My girlfriend and her mother did all the work on my house. The brokers only gave orders and were in the house perhaps once. I should have handed the actual task over to my girlfriend. But the stupid laws in this backwater country don't allow that and so the golf-playing bosses always wear the pants. I'm glad to have left this medieval and backward country with its many racist and completely out-of-time people behind me! The world keeps turning - but the islanders are too arrogant to notice that their hourglass has run out with Churchhill!
5/5
Just completed on our purchase. Claire and Reagan and Mairi all fantastic. Advice clear, communication rapid and calm reassurance very welcome. I recommend their conveyancing services
1/5
I have repeatedly called this agent regarding two properties. They don't know the properties, they give you stock replies to questions. Get defensive if you question their responses and then don't get back to you. How they sell properties I have no idea.
5/5
1st class service. Friendly staff
5/5
Excellent Estate Agent with friendly staff. A very good experiance when viewing a perspective property. Would certainly go through this company again when property viewing
5/5
Fantastic team, great experience from start to finish. Highly recommended.
5/5
Buzzy estate agents seems to sell propertys fast. Great staff happy to answer any questions.
5/5
Great company, good communication, prompt and efficient
5/5
Rating only, no written review.
Where the same review appears twice we show it once. We leave out reviews that name another agent or another of the brand's offices.
Irving Geddes WS's Comrie office has 11 reviews across 1 platform: 11 on Google. Reviews may appear on more than one platform. Checked 9 October 2026.
Irving Geddes WS is rated 3.6 out of 5 across all 11 reviews, and 3.6 out of 5 on Google from 11 reviews, checked 9 October 2026.
Irving Geddes WS, 1 Drummond Street, Comrie PH6 2DW.
Ratings and review counts checked 9 October 2026. Is this your office? Claim your page.